Preakness Analysis and Selections - Consensus
| Consensus | Big Brown (85) | Kentucky Bear (23) | Gayego (14) | Behindatthebar (8) |
| Steve Andersen | Andrew Beyer | Steven Crist | Chuck Dybdal |
| Behindatthebar | Big Brown | Big Brown | Big Brown |
| Big Brown | Gayego | Kentucky Bear | Behindatthebar |
| Gayego | Kentucky Bear | Gayego | Yankee Bravo |
| Kentucky Bear | Macho Again | Macho Again | Gayego |
| Ron Gierkink | David Grening | Mike Hammersly | Marcus Hersh |
| Kentucky Bear | Big Brown | Big Brown | Kentucky Bear |
| Big Brown | Kentucky Bear | Stevil | Gayego |
| Yankee Bravo | Hey Byrn | Kentucky Bear | Big Brown |
| Behindatthebar | Racecar Rhapsody | Gayego | Tres Borrachos |
| Jay Hovdey | Marty McGee | Jay Privman | Mary Rampellini |
| Big Brown | Big Brown | Big Brown | Big Brown |
| Icabad Crane | Yankee Bravo | Kentucky Bear | Gayego |
| Riley Tucker | Kentucky Bear | Gayego | Tres Borrachos |
| Yankee Bravo | Racecar Rhapsody | Racecar Rhapsody | Yankee Bravo |
| Bill Tallon | Brad Free | Byron King | Steve Klein |
| Big Brown | Big Brown | Big Brown | Big Brown |
| Icabad Crane | Tres Borrachos | Gayego | Gayego |
| Kentucky Bear | Giant Moon | Kentucky Bear | Macho Again |
| Gayego | Macho Again | Racecar Rhapsody | Riley Tucker |
| Dave Litfin | Mike Watchmaker | Mike Welsch | |
| Big Brown | Big Brown | Big Brown | |
| Racecar Rhapsody | Racecar Rhapsody | Kentucky Bear | |
| Behindatthebar | Gayego | Tres Borrachos | |
| Gayego | Kentucky Bear | Behindatthebar |