09/13/2016 7:33PM

'Mix-up' at Keeneland sale prevents Havre de Grace's colt from being sold


The buzz that had been building as the bay colt made his way toward the auction ring at the Keeneland September yearling sale reached a crescendo as bidding climbed to $1.9 million. However, that quickly turned to murmurs of surprise and disappointment when it was revealed that the War Front colt, out of 2011 Horse of the Year Havre de Grace, was, in fact, a high-ticket buyback.

No one was more surprised than the colt’s breeder, Mandy Pope – who later disclosed that there was a mistake made when entering the colt’s reserve, which caused him to officially become a buyback even though the bidding reached above the price she had intended. Pope declined to reveal the reserve and would not elaborate on how the error was made.

"I thought he had sold, and then I turned around and saw [Wayne Sweezey of consignor Timber Town],” said Pope, who described herself as “distraught” immediately following the hammer fall.

"Since I've been in this business, I always have been honest and done everything the right way, and I want people to understand that this was a total mix-up,” Pope said. “We had what we thought was a reasonable reserve on the horse, which many people were told. ... We told [buyers] the reserve was going to be one thing, then we ran it way past that. ... What I would like to say is, I apologize to all the agents who thought we were trying to take advantage of them.”

Pope purchased Havre de Grace, from the only crop of Saint Liam, for $10 million at the 2012 Fasig-Tipton Kentucky fall selected mixed sale – part of a buying spree of high-quality mares over the next two years that also included Kentucky Oaks winner Plum Pretty ($4.2 million, 2012 Keeneland November breeding stock sale) and champion Groupie Doll ($3.2 million, 2013 Keeneland November). Pope said at the time that she would likely retain fillies out of her mares to eventually join her broodmare band, but that male offspring would be sold to help recoup the investment.

Havre de Grace delivered a Tapit filly in the spring of 2014 at Timber Town in Lexington, where Pope boards her mares. Named Heavenly Grace, the filly is in training with Ralph Nicks at Belmont Park for Pope. After producing her War Front in 2015, Havre de Grace produced another Tapit filly this spring and was bred back to the leading sire for next spring.

"He came to the sale to be sold,” Pope said of this colt. “When I bring horses to sale, I bring them to sell them. If I don't want to sell them, they stay home. I have a 2-year-old filly out of Grace and a Tapit filly this year. I wanted to sell this one."

Pope indicated that options are open for the War Front colt, saying that Sweezey was reaching out to agents who had bid on the colt, but that she would also be amenable to racing him with a partner.

"The horse is still for sale at a reasonable price,” Pope said. “Hopefully, people will come back and look at him again. If they still have an interest, we still are interested in selling the horse. I would be interested in keeping a piece of the horse."

Racing for Rick Porter's Fox Hill Farm, Havre de Grace first emerged in the summer of 2010, finishing second to champion Blind Luck in three consecutive stakes, including the historic Grade 1 Alabama Stakes at Saratoga. She turned the tables on that rival with a win in the Grade 2 Cotillion Stakes. Blind Luck and Havre de Grace were second and third to Unrivaled Belle in the Breeders' Cup Ladies' Classic to end the season.

Havre de Grace won three Grade 1 events in her championship campaign the following season, highlighted by the Woodward Stakes, which she was only the second female to win. She also triumphed in the Apple Blossom Handicap and Beldame Stakes. Her only losses on the year came when a close second to Blind Luck in the Grade 2 Delaware Handicap and when a creditable fourth against males in the Breeders' Cup Classic.

Havre de Grace won the New Orleans Ladies Stakes to begin 2012 before an injury abruptly ended her career, with more than $2.5 million in earnings. Porter, who does not maintain a broodmare operation, offered her at the Fasig-Tipton sale, where Pope outlasted competitors in a long bidding war to secure her for the staggering eight-figure price tag. It was the highest price ever for a broodmare prospect sold at public auction, eclipsing the $9 million price for Ashado at the 2005 Keeneland November sale.

"The most important thing is the horse,” Pope said of her prize mare’s colt. “I want him to have a good home, and if it's with me, then that's what God intended."

:: DRF BREEDING LIVE: Real-time coverage of breeding and sales

Ryan Dewan Crawford More than 1 year ago

Hi, am here to share little testimony of how i got a real loan from Financial Home, i never believe on online loans lenders can be still real and legit this is because i have lost so many fee to scammers due to upfront fee being asked by them. but to the Glory of God Financial Loan Home assisted me with all the loan i needed they are real and legit. they lend me $15,000 usd which i used for my Son surgery. this loan company is for real give them a try if you need a loan and you will never regret contacting them, this is the company email address is financialhome34@outlook.com

MontrealKen More than 1 year ago
Quite a mix up. Can someone explain how bidding works when there is a reserve in place?
Jack Armstead More than 1 year ago

Ken... here is a link I found:   https://www.keeneland.com/sales/conditions-sale

All the other numbered terms of the Keeneland Sales link (above) are pretty easy to understand.  The mix-up that the article describes appears to be covered by the 4th term from the above link (see below).

I am still not 100% certain as to what Ms. Pope did or didn't do correctly. If the article's writer was unable to delve into or interview Ms. Pope directly (to discover the error in the "true" or "intended" reserve amount) then we won't really know 'How' or 'Why' this $1.9 M bid was ultimately rejected. 

If she accidentally put in a reserve of "$10.0 M" instead of "$1.0 M," then I would ultimately understand what happened.  I can only conclude that a person of Ms. Pope's experience must have "accidentally" put in an amount higher than the $1.9 bid... even though she verbally told everyone what the real reserve was. 

We have all transcribed things in error.  Just think of punching in the wrong bet on a SAM unit at the track or OTB.  Only this time, it was a huge error.

I feel that I must add that, if you can fully comprehend what transpired (from only reading this article and this 4th term; below); you must be very intelligent, or; psychic:


MISSED RESERVES: Keeneland shall us t efforts to adhere to reserves properly and timely placed (in accordance with time limits and other requirements established by Keeneland) with Keeneland at the reserve counter. In the event a horse is sold to a Purchaser for less than the reserve, Keeneland’s liability shall be limited to paying the Consignor an amount not to exceed the reserve less the commission charged on the sale. In the event a horse is sold with a reserve higher than that placed by the Consignor (including, without limitation, a reserve placed on a horse when none was directed by the Consignor), the horse if not sold to a Purchaser, at the option of Consignor, shall be brought back in the ring to be offered for sale and Seller, Consignor and Keeneland agree that Keeneland shall waive all of its commission, including any entry fees paid, as liquidated damages and neither party shall have any other rights, claims or obligations to the other arising out of the reserve error.

Frank More than 1 year ago
and DRF wants me to pay for their reporting -- Did they even proof read or QA this report -- The whole article is printed twice -

They are so sloppy and get many many facts wrong just like our liberal media today.