05/04/2013 9:31PM

Kentucky Derby: Orb storms home to win as the 5-1 favorite


LOUISVILLE, Ky. – There are times when horse racing can produce maddening, inexplicable results, waved away with a shrug and a common refrain, “That’s horse racing.”

Then there are times when everything comes together as if pre-ordained. The best jockey, on the best horse, prepared by the best trainer, bred by a family that has been competing at the top of racing for generations, wins the Kentucky Derby.

Barbara D. Livingston
Under the twin spires of Churchill Downs, Orb wins the 139th Kentucky Derby.

That, too, is horse racing.

So it was Saturday at Churchill Downs, at the 139th Kentucky Derby, when Orb brought trainer Shug McGaughey, the nation’s leading rider, Joel Rosario; and the families of Ogden Phipps and Stuart Janney III their first Derby victory with a convincing, 2 1/2-length win.

Orb ($12.80) went off the tepid favorite, the product of coming into the Derby with a four-race win streak and the positive impression he made all week here at Churchill Downs, including a sharp final workout Monday. Then he went out and ran like he trained.

[DRF LIVE AT THE KENTUCKY DERBY: News updates, photos, videos]

Over a track rated sloppy after extensive rain earlier in the day, Orb completed 1 1/4 miles in 2:02.89. The pace was surprisingly fast early – a half-mile in 45.33 seconds, six furlongs in 1:09.80 – and resulted in horses who were well back early sweeping the first three spots.

Orb was 16th of 19 during the early going. Golden Soul, a 34-1 shot, rallied from 15th to be second, one length in front of 6-1 second choice Revolutionary, who was 17th early but finished well enough along the inside to beat Normandy Invasion by a head for third.

Mylute was fifth and was followed, in order, by Oxbow, Lines of Battle, Will Take Charge, Charming Kitten, Giant Finish, Overanalyze, Palace Malice, Java’s War, Verrazano, Itsmyluckyday, Frac Daddy, Goldencents, Vyjack, and Falling Sky.

Revolutionary was the best of trainer Todd Pletcher’s five runners. Besides his third-place finish, Pletcher’s runners were ninth, 11th, 12th, and 14th. He has now won once with 36 starters in 13 Derbies.

[Results chart for 139th Kentucky Derby]

The victory was particularly satisfying for McGaughey, a Hall of Famer who is widely respected for the all the success he has had in the sport, and who – like the late Charlie Whittingham – only shows up at the Derby when he has a shot. He understands the demands it places on horses, and neither he nor his owners ever put their own self-interests ahead of their horses.

“I always dreamed of this day,” said McGaughey, who said he hadn’t even thought of coming to the Derby with Orb until he won the Florida Derby in his last start five weeks earlier.

“If you force a horse into a race, usually it ends up being a big mistake,” he said.

His approach is shared by Phipps and Janney, the co-owners of Orb, for whom McGaughey trains privately.

“He does it the right way,” Phipps said. “He takes his time. He lets the horse bring you to the race.”

Orb earned Janney and Phipps a first prize of $1,414,800 from a total race purse of $2,174,800. Janney and Phipps also bred Orb, a colt by Malibu Moon out of the Unbridled mare Lady Liberty.

A crowd of 151,616, the ninth-largest in history, stuffed itself into Churchill Downs on Saturday. Derby Day dawned cloudy, then the predicted rain moved in shortly after 10 a.m. and steadily soaked Churchill Downs for about seven hours. The rain stopped about 90 minutes before the Derby was run. The track was rated fast for the opener at 10:30 a.m., but was downgraded to sloppy midway through the day and remained rated sloppy through the Derby. This marked the fourth time in the last five years that the Derby was run on an off track.

A field of 19 – one short of the maximum that can run – went to the post after 21 horses were entered Wednesday. Fear the Kitten, the also-eligible, was withdrawn at scratch time Friday morning, and then two hours later, Black Onyx was scratched because of a chip in his left front ankle.

Considering the size of the field and the wet conditions, the race was surprisingly cleanly run, owing to a rapid pace that spread the field out and prevented a traffic jam heading into the first turn. Palace Malice, in blinkers for the first time, rocketed out of the gate and sprinted to a 3 1/2-length lead through that rapid first half-mile and six furlongs, with Oxbow and Verrazano closest.

Orb, starting from post 16, got a gorgeous trip from Rosario, who let the bulk of the field clear him, then dropped behind 15 rivals and saved a decent amount of ground on the first turn by getting to a path about three widths from the rail.

“I thought Joel did a great job getting position going around the first turn,” McGaughey said.

Rosario kept Orb in the middle of the track down the backstretch, befitting a rider who was confident he was on the best horse and did not want to risk getting him stopped.

As the field went around the far turn, Orb began an extended, powerful rally outside rivals and went from one of the trailers at the three-furlong pole to a looming threat at the three-sixteenths pole.

Once straightened away, Orb took aim on Normandy Invasion, who briefly hit the front approaching the quarter pole. McGaughey thought Orb eased up a bit once he hit the front with less than a furlong remaining, but Rosario is a powerful finisher, and he was not going to let Orb dawdle.

“I got a little antsy, but he did go on and finish,” McGaughey said.

Orb will move on to the second leg of the Triple Crown, the Preakness Stakes at Pimlico on May 18, and try to keep hopes alive of being the first Triple Crown winner since Affirmed in 1978. He would need to add the Preakness as well as the Belmont Stakes on June 8 to join 11 other 3-year-olds who have won all three legs of the Triple Crown. The 35-year drought is the longest since Sir Barton first won the Triple Crown in 1919.

Orb was scheduled to head to New York – where McGaughey is based from spring to fall – on Sunday morning and be prepared for the Preakness.

“He has been coming out of his races good,” McGaughey said. “I’ve actually been surprised how well he has come out of his races. If everything’s right, I can’t wait to get there and do it again.”

bill n More than 1 year ago
Mylute finished 5th. not 4th. DRF.
Gary Goodrich More than 1 year ago
I've seen some Lukas bashing about being garbage horses entered in the triple crown races. Maybe you people should pump your brakes. He's won alot of these races at long odds,I think he knows what he's doing. Thinder Gulch at 25-1 wins the derby. Grindstone coupled with Editor's Note was 4-1, but Grindstone's odds were 35-1 without being coupled. Charismatic at 33-1,Commendable at 31-1 in the Belmont. Also Proud Citizen 25-1 finished second to War Emblem in 2002. He's paid off some huge exactas and win bets. I hope he gets one of these legs to shut up the bashing. Will Take Charge is going to be a serious threat in these next two legs on a fast track. I didn't like the 6 week layoff coming in to the Derby. Deeds not Words was his worst entry, I think it was to keep the streak. I can't help it I think he's one of the greatest ever.
Danny C More than 1 year ago
Orb will win the triple crown this year. Why?, Not because he is a super good horse like affirmed or secretariat but because he is an exceptional horse in a class of 3 year old that is not very strong. As long as he comes out of each leg ok, he will win the triple crown
Sam Shelby More than 1 year ago
Oh. And it cracks me up to no living end that Revolutionary was almost the favorite. News flash. Borel won 3 derbies. That does not make him a lock to win the derby. That doesnt even make him a good jockey. Him making the hall of fame is like Don Larsen making the hall of fame for that perfect game.
Mark More than 1 year ago
Went off second choice and ran third. It cracks me up you didn't have Dallas' horse for second .
Sam Shelby More than 1 year ago
Who said I did`nt?
Sam Shelby More than 1 year ago
bill n More than 1 year ago
Sam why is everything you write dumb>?
Sam Shelby More than 1 year ago
I would like to congratulate Orb, Shug McGaughey, and Joel Rosario in advance for winning the 1st triple crown in 35 yrs. Theres no other 3 yr old like him.
[removed] More than 1 year ago
This comment has been deleted
Dave More than 1 year ago
He entered knowing Wise Dan was in it. If it were a firm turf it would have been a hell of a horse race.
Jason Hart More than 1 year ago
Fantastic performance by Orb. I singled him on top of 12 other horses in the tri and STILL DIDN'T HIT IT!!! This race is by far the most difficult race to handicap most years. Where are all the Dreaming Of Julia folks, who said she would win the derby if she could have entered? She ran TWO SECONDS faster than Orb at GP remember? Bla bla bla..... Just goes to show times mean very little. And before you start talking about her rough trip, just know it was nothing like Will Take Charge's trip in the derby. But he is being called garbage on this board, even though he would have finished at least 2nd if he doesn't almost get dropped in the lane.
Mark More than 1 year ago
Careful what you wish for Jason.
riconap More than 1 year ago
@Jason - I have been a more than reasonably proficient and successful handicapper for about 50 years and I agree with your assessment that raw time is among the least important factors when selecting a winner.However, don't dismiss its' relative importance when the conditions of track surface, level of competition and the pace factor are taken into consideration.
Jason Hart More than 1 year ago
That was my point. Every race sets up differently, which completely determines the final time. Final times are not completely meaningless, but like I said, they mean very little.
Mark More than 1 year ago
Trips . Julia's was a nightmare . Hope to see her in belmont. Settle it on track.
Mark More than 1 year ago
Agree on WTC
Robert More than 1 year ago
jason u are absolutely correct ..........TIMEis only important when are serving it or u two timing youre significant other...having eye witnessed ORB in his against the bias florida DEFBY triumph{ big profit made] and the greatest pinnacle of his ..shug ....joel... and the janney/phipps ownership ....kudos to all and thank u very much for the new OAKS/WISE DAN MATCH RACE[with himself].....I had the pleasure of meeting SHUG 22 years ago at Tony s Wood Pizza across from the SPA ater the sunday races and for a trainer of his statue to take 15 minutes of his time to converse with one of ordinary people[not the whitneys or vanderbilts or the kadashians....lol...was extra ordinary...a genine person and consumate trainer......forget about money.....I have never been happier for a fellow human being in the racing game in my 40 years of donating to this fabulous hobby of ours...ranks right up with meeting ang greeting UNBRIDLED and visiting SECRTARIAT S final resting place at Clairborne farm in paris kentucky.....TRIPLE CROWN in sight....heres hopeing AFFIRMED...SEATTLE SLEW....BIG RED.[SECRTARIAT] ...CITATION and the rest wil make room mr turfbobbie
B More than 1 year ago
So the best horse won. I liked him. I bet on him. Shug deserves it. I'm glad it's over with and I am outta here.
[removed] More than 1 year ago
This comment has been deleted
Thomas Cook More than 1 year ago
Maybe he just didn't want to hurt his turf star on a boggy course? Again doing right by the horse.
Lawrence Vaccarelli More than 1 year ago
did you happen to notice the length of the grass ? a freaking cat or small dog would get lost........
[removed] More than 1 year ago
This comment has been deleted
jttf More than 1 year ago
how come shug didnt scratch his POE when he won the grade 1 turf classic on yeilding turf ? some people are too short sighted on noticing that horse likes soft turf. everyone fears wise dan on any surface.
Billy Spathanas More than 1 year ago
There will be a next time , we shall see then, patience...
Mike Rutledge More than 1 year ago
I would like to point out something just for fun. I counted 8 horses who had run on off tracks. They finished 3rd,8th,10th,12th,15th,16th,18th & 19th. Only 3 of them were even in the top 1/2 of the race. I took the top 8 Thomalson (?) #s & they finished 4th,5th,8th,13th,14th,15th,17th & 18th. Only 3 of them were in the top 1/2 of the race. I had posted yesterday about changing my pick for a fast track when it rains. Never again, I'll keep that super and then pick another combo for the rain but my big bet will still be my original picks for a fast track. You just don't know whats going to happen when these 3yr olds run on an off track.
Robert Smith More than 1 year ago
Not all mud is the same.
Lawrence Vaccarelli More than 1 year ago
very true, most people don't understand that
riconap More than 1 year ago
With the passage of time, exponential breeding has weakened the importance of wet track bloodline prowess. when I first started handicapping about 50 years ago the racing papers used three different symbols to designate wet track blood line and performance ability ( now Tomlinson #) and today that analysis is worth far less and will be worth even less in the future so stick with your fast track choice and make modifications where you think it is worthwhile.