07/03/2013 4:09PM

Jay Hovdey: Wise Dan joins great ones who win against all odds

Churchill Downs/Reed Palmer Photography
Wise Dan overcomes poor footing and an eventful trip to win the Firecracker Handicap.

Now that all the overnight ratings are in regarding Wise Dan’s performance in last weekend’s Firecracker Handicap – ranging from "big deal look who he beat" to "how dare they run him under such conditions" – it is time to turn the case over to the judgment of history and let the verdict settle to its natural level.

No less an authority as Charlie LoPresti, Wise Dan’s trainer, said, "It wasn’t a very pretty race," and he should know. Together they have painted some masterpieces, led by last year’s Breeders’ Cup Mile at Santa Anita and the Woodbine Mile in Canada. But LoPresti is the guy who puts his hands on Wise Dan’s legs every morning and worries late into the night about what comes next. He is not the guy who gets to sign off on posterity, however, because the Firecracker was an old-school work of art.

Winning ugly is backing into fat purse via disqualification. Winning ugly is staggering home first after a 14-second final furlong. Winning ugly is having the horse on your hip go wrong in the last hundred yards.

Any old champion can win when the stars are aligned. Secretariat in the Belmont, Damascus in the Travers, Landaluce in the Hollywood Lassie – nice work if you can get it.

But show me a champ who’s cut by a lace in the first round, or handed the stove and told to run up a hill and still, in spite of all the reasons to cave, comes through in the end.

In fairness, LoPresti merely was expressing his everlasting admiration in the immediate aftermath of what Wise Dan went through carrying 128 pounds, giving away 11 to 13, in a downpour over ground that would have brought Patton’s Third Army to its knees.

In addition, Wise Dan had the privilege of being ridden in the Firecracker not only by John Velazquez, but to one degree or another by Corey Lanerie, Jon Court, Rosie Napravnik, and Brian Hernandez, all of whom did their best to keep the reigning Horse of the Year handcuffed and surrounded, like a perp heading for the slam.

"When you’re on the favorite you’re fair game for everybody," said Angel Cordero Jr., who books mounts for fellow Hall of Famer Velazquez. "They’re going to try and make it hard for you. That’s part of the sport. But you know that going in, so you’ve got to be smart enough to know where to go and when to go."

Cordero did not exactly write the book on the subject, but he did conduct a career-long master class of riding that fine line.

"As long as you don’t bump the favorite, or do anything illegal, you do what you can to get him beat," Cordero said. "A good horse will overcome all that."

Wise Dan’s Firecracker was reminiscent of some very special races in which a superior horse faced conditions that provided every excuse for losing.

On Sept. 11, 1968, Dr. Fager ran on the grass for the first and only time in the United Nations Handicap at Atlantic City. It was the 21st race of his 22-race career. He carried 134 pounds, conceding 22 pounds to Advocator (a son of grass champ Round Table, who won the 1959 U.N. Handicap under 136) and 16 pounds to both the Australian star Tobin Bronze and Fort Marcy, a future Hall of Famer.

The course was firm but the long grass was damp and slick from rain the night before as Dr. Fager pulled Braulio Baeza immediately to the lead. The big colt fishtailed around the tight first turn and fought the footing all the way around. Through the final quarter Advocator and Laffit Pincay headed and passed them more than once, while Baeza tried to hold Dr. Fager’s compromised stride together. In the end, Dr. Fager was simply too much horse. The winning margin was a neck. Nerud’s reaction?

"He must have run as good as he ever ran in his life," the trainer said.

On the night of Oct. 2, 1976, Bill Shoemaker was enjoying life in a Manhattan watering hole when the TV above the bar showing the day’s sports action caught his attention.

"Watch this," he said to a companion. "Tell me I didn’t lose this race."

There on the screen, the final quarter-mile of the 1 1/4-mile Marlboro Cup was unfolding in a river of Belmont Park slop. The 3-year-old Honest Pleasure was on the lead and loving it – the same Honest Pleasure who had won the Champagne by seven over the same kind of surface and set a Saratoga record in the 1 1/4-mile Travers. Somewhere out back and to the outside, the reigning two-time Horse of the Year Forego – all 1,200 pounds of him – was skidding and slipping around, with Shoemaker trying to keep the big horse balanced.

Then it happened. Forego caught his stride, and in the final sixteenth of a mile he appeared to be skipping over the top of the slop. Shoemaker steered straight and caught Honest Pleasure in literally the final stride of the 10 furlongs to win by a head. Forego carried 137 pounds, Honest Pleasure 119.

"It was the greatest race I’ve ever been in or seen," Shoemaker said.

No one disagreed, although Shoemaker did have second thoughts five years later after winning the inaugural running of the Arlington Million with John Henry.

The Arlington Park turf was deep – Firecracker deep – on that muggy afternoon of Aug. 30, 1981, when the first seven-figure American Thoroughbred race was run. John Henry was the reigning grass champion, but he’d never tried grass like this before, and his gliding, daisy-cutting stride seemed ripe for grief over the dead, holding ground.

From the bell, it was apparent John Henry was off his rhythm, just as it was clear The Bart, with his high-kneed action and thoroughly European pedigree, was loving it. Shoemaker did what Shoemaker did best, which was let his horse try to find a comfort zone. At first, John Henry was frustrated. Then the pro took over and he adjusted his stride. John Henry was still deep in the pack when they turned for home, and with a furlong to run his task still seemed hopeless.

But just as Forego caught fire with the wire in sight, John Henry clawed away at The Bart’s advantage. At the finish, The Bart’s nose was up and John Henry’s was down. Both of them slept well that night.

Correction: An earlier version of this article misstated the weight Wise Dan carried and conceded to rivals in the Firecracker. He carried 128 pounds, not 127, and conceded 11 to 13 pounds, not 11 to 15.

John Doe More than 1 year ago
Wise Dan's "weak competition" did well this weekend. Flat Out (G2 Suburban H. Winner), beaten by nearly 7 lengths by Wise Dan. Big Blue Kitten (G1 United Nations Winner) beaten by nearly 11 lengths Wise Dan.
therealdubwhite More than 1 year ago
anyone able to see the Poker Handicap today in which Data Link, last out 1 length behind Wise Dan failed to hit the board in a Grade 3 at Belmont today on the turf. Oh how he flattered the #HorseOfTheYear. What stellar horses he's running against and defeating.
John Doe More than 1 year ago
He had zero pace today and ran flat. There's no question he's better than that. Unfortunately for your theory, Skyring (also coming out of the Makers Mark) came back and won the Dixie Stakes (G2). What else you got?
hialeah More than 1 year ago
I like the article and believe that the four main points of interest were all HoY (some more than others). From the "You can't make this up" file: NYRA - Belmont, Scratches & Changes: R-3, I Grieve for U - Gelding. Long may he run.
HorseAlerts More than 1 year ago
JV knows how to lose races on heavy favorites. Wise Dan just wasn't going to play along.
Bob More than 1 year ago
I don't know that I would call Secretariat "any old champion..." His win in the Belmont Stakes was not only the first Triple Crown sweep in 25 years, it was perhaps the greatest display of pure thoroughbred talent in the history of the sport and it clearly established Big Red's right to be considered among perhaps the four or five greatest thoroughbreds to ever set foot on the racetrack!
Gaye Goodwin More than 1 year ago
Nattering naybobs of negativity! My lord! Wise Dan has found the heart to win, convincingly, in his last two races in conditions where a loss would have been acceptable. Go ahead - find a handful of Thoroughbreds that can do that in any age. Methinks these critics simply are the devil's advocate because they think it makes them seem smarter than those with the aptitude to recognize what is truly admirable. They are sadly mistaken!
Dee R. Eff More than 1 year ago
Uhmmm, did I read that right? You really think that Wise Dan's win in the Firecracker ranks on equal terms with Dr. Fager carrying 134 in the United Nations Handicap, and Forego carrying 137 to beat Honest Pleasure in the Marlboro Cup, and also the feats of John Henry? Seriously? Not in the Firecracker and not yet. Was there a memo that went out that all DRF writers must write accolades about Wise Dan? I think this is about the fourth in two days. He's a really nice horse that deserves a lot of credit, but he ain't no Forego, or Dr. Fager or even John Henry. Not yet.
Grazyna Mianska More than 1 year ago
Spot On!
therealdubwhite More than 1 year ago
Actually he aint no Goldikova or Cape Blanco, and to this point yet he's unproven at anything over 9f on turf so thus far he's no Little Mike or Point of Entry. But I do have to ask if anyone was able to see the Poker Handicap today in which Data Link, last out 1 length behind Wise Dan failed to hit the board in a Grade 3 at Belmont today on the turf. Oh how he flattered the #HorseOfTheYear. What stellar horses he's running against and defeating.
Big Jeff More than 1 year ago
pete and repeat
Eddie Smith More than 1 year ago
This article could be used as the poster child for hyperbole in a college writing course. Overkill, to the max.
JayHovdey More than 1 year ago
Thank you Eddie. I remember taking that course but ended up ditching it to play the late double at Turf Paradise -- JH
redboy More than 1 year ago
Secretariat was 3 and was the best horse of his racing year.To even mention the stara were aligned.Is disrepectful to the great horse He was and will always be endeared by racing fans far and wide.
B More than 1 year ago
There may have been a better horse before Secretariat, but there has not been one better since.
redboy More than 1 year ago
No doubt .i would have loved to have seen some of the greats .prior to Sec. II love to Sec. Take on some of the recent G1 winners with his A game. Sec vs Fort Larned Sec vs Zenyatta sec vs Ak Secretariat turns for home Zenyatta winding up,and unleashes her run. Secretariat and Fort Larned at the 1/16th He was a Great animal
hialeah More than 1 year ago
JH wrote, "Secretariat in the Belmont", you know, THE Belmont where he won by over 30 lengths and shattered the 12 furlong track record in a time that will never be broken unless they start racing with jet packs. Anyone that viewed that race knew the stars were, in fact, respectfully aligned.
redboy More than 1 year ago
Yes Im well aware of THE Belmont in which he won by over 30 Lengths. But if memory service me correct he had just broken the track records in THE Derby and THE Preakness,So exactly how did the stars have to be aligned for him to break the Belmont record? What were the several factors that led to the star(s) being aligned? Did the race breakdown in front of him,did his main competition scratch,exactly what ocured that led to the star(s) being aligned? He ran to the front ,disposed of his main threat at the 3/4 pole and never looked back at THE Belmont!
Mr. Ed More than 1 year ago
I have to correct you. Secretariat did not break the Preakness record prior to running in the Belmont. He was given the Preakness record after a time adjustment just last year, 39 years after the race. So many factors came together in 1973 for that one time for such an accomplishment of one horse to occur. The stars were indeed aligned.
Mr. Ed More than 1 year ago
Sorry, Maybe I should have said THE Preakness.
redboy More than 1 year ago
We can agree to disagree. Several factors(stars)were aligned to give Sec the opportunity to win the Belmont in such convincing and record breaking fashion? What were they? Was there a 60 mph whirl wind at the track that day,and with the stars being aligned the wind switched on every stretch and since he had no athletic ability to speak of it was a Stars aligned winded aided Belmont WIN? Who knows you might be right I think I heard The Silver Surfer was in the area at the time!
Mr. Ed More than 1 year ago
The problem Redboy is you seem to be having trouble understanding what having the stars aligned actually means. All of the insignificant specific race things you are attempting to interject into the conversation on the subject have little to do with it, although there are a few which you won't like, so I won't get into it. I don't want to burst your love bubble. You need to do some research rather than just spew
Mr. Ed More than 1 year ago
Redboy, don't think about the stars being aligned, just think about how truly great of a race horse he was to be able to break THE Preakness record 39 years after they ran the race.
B More than 1 year ago
A really good article. The good old days. Will we ever see the likes of a Forego or a John Henry again?! Probably not, but if we do it will have to be a gelding, so here's hoping that Game On Dude and Wise Dan have fantastic and lengthy careers.