02/27/2014 4:44PM

Jay Hovdey: Gotham's glory days long gone

Michael Amoruso
Samraat will try to win the Gotham Stakes, which has a rich history but hasn't had much of an impact on the Triple Crown for years.

You’ve got to hand it to the Gotham Stakes. If it had a voice and could wave its arms, it would be up on a tabletop shouting, “I am somebody! I am somebody!”

To be fair it was, once upon a time, when for more than 40 years the Gotham had a safe and secure home as a one-turn mile over the Aqueduct main track on a date not normally associated with snowfall.

“It was huge then,” said Richie Migliore, who regularly rode winters in New York. “It was always a big deal to ride the race. And even when I was growing up it was a race you paid attention to, because that’s where New York’s Derby horses showed up all the time.”

That was then. Now, in an effort to put lipstick on a Grade 3 race contested over a chemically treated dirt track – I’m sorry, but “winterized” is not a word, unless we get to use “summerific” in California – the New York Racing Association has increased the Gotham purse to a chilly half a million, while Churchill Downs Inc. contributes 85 precious points toward qualification for the Kentucky Derby.

Still, for the Gotham to be taken seriously, a horse needs to emerge from its current conditions to at least do something somewhere in the Triple Crown, which has yet to happen. A field of 11 was entered for Saturday’s running, with New York natives Samraat and Uncle Sigh leading the way.

Beginning in 1953, the first seven runnings of the Gotham took place at Jamaica Race Course, which went out of business in 1959 and was replaced by a housing development. That first Gotham was split, which gave Laffango a chance to win the second division because he was never going to beat Native Dancer in the first. Native Dancer went on to win the Preakness, the Belmont and everything else but the Kentucky Derby.

When Eddie Arcaro retired at the end of the 1961 season, he left a lot on the table. One of the best was Jaipur, who made his 1962 debut in the Gotham under Bill Shoemaker and beat Sunrise County by 1 1/2 lengths. Jaipur was not nominated to the Kentucky Derby, but passing the race did not keep him from winning the Withers, the Belmont and the Travers to be voted 3-year-old champ.

Dr. Fager and Damascus met for the first time in the 1967 Gotham Stakes in what turned out to be a harbinger of their two-year rivalry. Damascus, coming off a win in the seven-furlong Bay Shore, was on the engine for Bill Shoemaker and in front of Dr. Fager until deep in the stretch. That’s when Manny Ycaza asked Dr. Fager for just enough to put Damascus away by a half-length. Dr. Fager went on to win six more stakes that year (he was DQ’d from a seventh), while Damascus ended 1967 as Horse of the Year with 11 stakes wins, including the Preakness, the Belmont, the Travers and the Jockey Club Gold Cup.

Secretariat, the reigning Horse of the Year, already had flexed his muscles in 1973, bulling his way to victory in the Bay Shore Stakes, his first start as a 3-year-old. Ron Turcotte was in no mood to let traffic be a factor in the Gotham, so he let Secretariat fly and appeared to have the race in hand with a quarter of a mile to run. Then the stubborn Champagne Charlie made a run that put him alongside Secretariat at the eighth pole, but that was as close as he got. Big Red won by three in stakes-record time.

The 1989 running of the Gotham presented reigning 2-year-old champion Easy Goer with an opportunity to enhance his growing reputation as the best New York-based colt since the days of Secretariat. This he did, in spades, with a 13-length victory under Pat Day’s hand ride in a stakes-record 1:32.40. Easy Goer went on to an unprecedented sweep of the Belmont, the Whitney, the Travers, the Woodward, and the Jockey Club Gold Cup.

Even as the impact of the Gotham waned and other Kentucky Derby preliminaries gained traction, there have been key runnings.

In 1992, the Gotham ended in a dead heat between Lure, a future Hall of Famer, and Devil His Due, who went on to win nearly $4 million. Three years later, the 1-2 finishers in the Gotham were Talkin Man, who came right back to take the Wood Memorial, and Da Hoss, best known for his pair of wins in the Breeders’ Cup Mile.

Migliore ended up winning three Gothams – with Eternal Prince in 1985, Alysweep in 2003, and Survivalist in 2005.

“It should have been four, but I gave one of them away to Julie,” Migliore said. “In ’96 I was riding both Feather Box and Romano Gucci. I thought Feather Box was bred to go further so I went with him, and she picked up the mount.”

Feather Box ended up finishing third, for which there is no memento. But a quick search through the trophy case here at home – which I am obligated by the fine print of marriage vows to regularly dust – discovered a silver julep cup inscribed to “Herbert Kushner’s Romano Gucci – Jockey Julie Krone.” There’s just enough time to give it a polish before Saturday.

John Whalen More than 1 year ago
hey i work at track for pinkerton for 11 years nyra they gave me a pension of 62 a month no medical
1971 Whippet More than 1 year ago
C'mon Jay, don't be so hard on the NYRA,, trying to make the Gotham relevant. Maybe, someday, people will show up for the races that feed the Wood Memorial or even the Gotham. It's possible. Lacking the Saratoga atmosphere or the possibility of a Triple Crown winner, people don't go to the races in New York. Thirty-seven years ago, do you know how many of us saw Seattle Slew in the Wood? Fewer than 20,000 for an undefeated (likely) derby favorite.
jttf More than 1 year ago
race fans would like to see the best horses run more often. but now it is a huge health issue with use of lasix. horsemen and vets did not do enough research before they dove head first ino the lasix developed pool. they did the same thing with synthetic tracks. goodbye to the 70 and 80s style of racing.
prose More than 1 year ago
Richard, I disagree with your comments. On the one hand, racing does not hold the fascination it did for the casual fan. 1000s don't show up on weekends regularly. Jockey are not household names and national sports figures. They once were. On the other hand, horse racing IS the horse, and a great horse can come from anywhere at anytime to energize the game. I got into racing because of a horse named Cigar and his popularity. I remember millions being energized by Funny Cide's and Smarty Jones' try for the triple-crown. Anything can happen in racing to create great drama and spectacle. But, you're right, racing won't ever attain again it's importance in the public mind because state lotteries and casinos have forever impinged on its territory. Without gambling, there is no racing.
Richard More than 1 year ago
First of all, the " glory days" of all horse racing are well past being " long gone. " As far as the existing east coast product being compared to the weather coast product - unfortunately for Jay - there is no comparison. The field sizes, the purses, the contests, the racetracks, the Riders and the Trainers are all superior in the east.
dazed and confused More than 1 year ago
Jay, your left coast bias is showing.
mark oleary More than 1 year ago
Great little story here! Well done and well researched, and I especially love that race by Easy Goer in the INSANE time of 1:32.40 for a mile! Races like the Gotham have such a rich and storied history in the annals of horseracing, and the horses that competed in it ( and not neccesarily win it) are legengs in our game. It's wonderful to watch all the 3 year olds gearing up for their run for the roses, but somewhat disconcerting that fillies all of a sudden have become irrelevant to the Triple Crown quest. In fact, the points system for entry for the Kentucky Derby unfairly penalizes the fillies, because they get no points for their races, including their difficult Grade I features, that lead up to their Derby equivilants. There is nothing more exciting than the thoughts of some amazon filly dominating her sex and ready to take on the boys. It adds a whole new dimension to the process.
Ann More than 1 year ago
Fillies can gain points if they run against the boys, which used to be commoner than you think. Althea won the Arkansas Derby, Winning Colors and Silver Spoon won the Santa Anita Derby, Genuine Risk was a close third in the Wood Memorial. Just a couple of years ago, her folks were thinking of running On Fire Baby in the Derby, so she ran in the Smarty Jones at Oaklawn early in the season to see if she fit with them; she ran an okay third, but they decided if she didn't beat this lot, she probably couldn't handle the Derby. Fillies can gain points if their people run her in Derby preps.
seattle More than 1 year ago
For those who didn't understand what I was correcting or noting: I was correcting and noting the fact that Easy Goer's record is a still standing "Track Record" of 1:32 2/5 for almost 25 years and counting, not just a "stakes record."
Hail No More than 1 year ago
No problem, your first post was fine and accurate, We didn't time in hundredths back then if I remember correctly, so you are correct, we don't know if it was 132:41- .59..
seattle More than 1 year ago
Actually I think we do, though not sure 100%. 1989 was the first year NYRA timed in hundredths. I say this because Easy Goer's record is listed at exactly 1:32.40 by the nyra website. And if you search Easy Goer's Belmont Stakes you will find it the final time was 2:26.01 or 2:26 flat of course, and the article stated it was timed in hundredths(for the first time). A.P. Indy's final time was 2:26.13. So, if not for Secretariat of course, Easy Goer would have the stakes record, not A.P.Indy.
Hail No More than 1 year ago
I just popped an old vcr tape in, they didn't measure in the 100ths on the infield board or on screen graphics. Amazing, still,(6 in 8and3/5) Day was "just hanging on" and the Big Guy did it so effortlessly, what a horse :)
seattle More than 1 year ago
In the June 12, 1989 NY Times article(which you can find on the web) "Easy Goer's Other Victory by Steve Crist, Crist states, "Easy Goer's final time of 2:26.01 for a mile and a half - this was the FIRST Triple Crown race officially timed in hundredths of a second -was the second-fastest Belmont; the fastest was Secretariat's world-record 2:24 in 1973, widely considered the most brilliant racing performance in the last 20 years. Fast running times are often largely the product of extremely lively track surfaces, but Easy Goer's was not. Six other races were run on the main dirt track at Belmont yesterday, and not one of them was more than one full second faster than average."
Hail No More than 1 year ago
Thanks for that :) I'm lazy, I wish racing had it's own google, but I'll look that up, thx again :) PS, EG was one running sunofagun, I know his record, minus SS was stellar and one of the best, period :)
Matthew Ellis More than 1 year ago
I also thought THUNDER GULCH won the Gotham.
Blaine MacMillan More than 1 year ago
No he did not. Won the Remsen at Aqueduct as a 2yo, but took the FOY/Florida Derby/Bluegrass route on his way to winning the Kentucky Derby...
hialeah More than 1 year ago
Coulda sworn that Stay Thirsty won the the Gotham way back in 2011, and followed with: a 2nd in the Belmont, and wins in the jim Dandy, Travers and Cigar Mile (a nose on Groupie Doll). Could be a good one this week, as well. We'll see.
Ann More than 1 year ago
Stay Thirsty did indeed win the Gotham, but he made no show in the Kentucky Derby. And a close second to a distinctly modest Belmont winner like Ruler on Ice on an off track isn't making much noise.