06/06/2013 12:53PM

Jay Hovdey: 1993 Belmont evokes memories joyous and sad

Email
NYRA photo
Julie Krone makes history winning the 1993 Belmont Stakes aboard Colonial Affair.

A guy can get in trouble for forgetting an anniversary, only around this house that can mean the marking of a date entirely different from a specific Saturday in the foggy past when vows were exchanged and somebody kissed the bride.

It has been 20 years since Colonial Affair emerged from the gloom of a rainy New York afternoon to carry Julie Krone and the colors of Centennial Farms to victory in the 125th running of the Belmont Stakes. Krone was the first woman to ride the winner of a Triple Crown race, which apparently was a big deal at the time and gave her the right, when asked, to say, “Yes, I did.”

The “I do” came later.

It is hard to avoid reminders around this house, from the visage of horse and rider beaming down from the Fred Stone print, to the “Colonial Affair” saddle towel with the green “4” draped over her mother’s tack trunk, to the shadow box with the petrified carnation from the victory blanket, to the jockey’s trophy awarded that year which is, of all things, an English silver café au lait pot from F. Gorevic & Son of New York, labeled “London, 1935.” At least I’m not the oldest thing in her collection.

[BELMONT STAKES: Live updates and video from Belmont Park]

The memory of the day has to last because the mortal members of the cast fade away. Scotty Shulhofer, who brimmed with confidence in his colt as he legged up his jockey, died in December 2006 at age 80 after a Hall of Fame career that included a second Belmont with Lemon Drop Kid in 1999. Don Little Sr., the founder of the Centennial syndicate, was a vigorous 77 when he died in February 2012 from injuries suffered in a fall while riding in the Winter Equestrian Festival in Wellington, Fla.

More recently the Thoroughbred world lost Colonial Affair himself, who was standing at stud in Argentina when his death was announced in April. A son of Pleasant Colony, who famously lost the Belmont in an attempt to sweep the 1981 Triple Crown, Colonial Affair was even better at 4 than 3, winning both the Whitney Handicap at Saratoga and the Jockey Club Gold Cup at Belmont to be among the leading vote-getters for the 1994 Eclipse best older male.

The jockey, happy to say, is in fine health and will be on the edge of her seat Saturday for the 145th running of the Belmont Stakes. Krone keeps her cards close (although I do follow her to the window), so at this point it’s hard to say if she likes her old pal Shug McGaughey to bounce back with Derby winner Orb, or for Rosie Napravnik and Unlimited Budget to make a splashy all-female statement, or for Gary Stevens to keep making the rest of the 50-year-olds out there feeling young with Oxbow. Krone is still 49.

“Is Mikey riding the race?” she wondered.

Yes, he is. Mike Smith, Krone’s longtime friend and winner of the 2010 Belmont aboard Drosselmeyer, will be back aboard Dogwood Stable’s Palace Malice on Saturday in an attempt to cleanse the palate after their performance in the Kentucky Derby. Students of sensible pace howled to the heavens when the son of Curlin took his handsome new set of blinkers as a cue to go as fast as he could for as far as he could at Churchill Downs, which was only about a mile of the mile and a quarter, before fading to finish 12th behind Orb.

Palace Malice’s half-mile split of 45.33 seconds was not the fastest in the history of the Derby, but it was the fourth fastest, going back to 1875. For the record, those green blinkers are staying on a hook back at the Todd Pletcher barn Saturday afternoon, which is just fine with his jockey. Smith was asked if he is anxious to give the colt another chance.

“Boy am I,” he replied. “I think he ran a sneaky good race in the Derby. He didn’t just fold at the top of the stretch, he hung in there and kept trying. If he can relax and get in a good rhythm, he should be able to go on and maybe surprise some people on Saturday.”

Having finished a close second in the Blue Grass Stakes on Keeneland’s synthetic surface, Palace Malice was expected to enjoy the wet, tightly rolled surface he encountered on Derby Day.

“He did,” Smith said. “I think it was the sound behind him that got him going, because he just tucked his tail and took off. He couldn’t see what was chasing him, but he knew something was back there.”

The fright-flight instincts of the Thoroughbred are deeply ingrained, and when one of them decides to flee there is literally no stopping him. The slapping clatter of hooves on the sloppy table-top of a sealed track can be deafening, especially when magnified by 18 pursuers in a bowl of sound amplified by a Kentucky Derby crowd.

“I think he thought somebody was shooting at him with a machine gun,” Smith said. “That’s how it sounded.”

As far as 20th anniversaries go, Smith would just as soon forget about the worst parts of 1993 Belmont Stakes, if people would quit reminding him. He was riding Prairie Bayou, fresh from winning the Preakness and favored in the third leg of the Crown, when the colt fractured his left foreleg on the backstretch. The reins were yanked from Smith’s hands and he fell, after which Prairie Bayou continued to stagger down the track on three legs. The fractured was compounded, leaving vets nothing to do but mercifully euthanize the colt.

“Turning for home I was looking for Mike, because I knew he’d be coming,” Krone recalled of that day. “When we all pulled up he was the only one missing, and then I saw all the commotion on the backstretch.

“I had given Mike a picture of him with Prairie Bayou taken the year before at Saratoga,” Krone added. “He loved that horse. When I saw him after the race I could hardly say anything except ‘I’m so sorry.’ He was surrounded by reporters, crying.”

Smith will let us know when he gets over it.

“When it comes to that day I like to think about Julie winning,” Smith said. “It’s too sad to think about the other thing. If he hadn’t lost his life it wouldn’t have been near as bad. But he was my favorite.”

Which is why disappointments like the more recent Derby roll off Smith’s thick hide. Palace Malice is back to fight another day.

“Todd’s said he’s been training real well,” Smith said. “I suppose it would be a great surprise if he won, but it really wouldn’t be a shocker to me. Stranger things have happened.”

Ann Ferland More than 1 year ago
I totally missed all of the 1993 Triple Crown. We were on sabbatical in Chile (great telescopes in Chile for astronomer husband) and all I got live was the Armed Forces Radio call of the Derby. Thank you for filling in the gaps from the raw results for me.
Debra Medlock More than 1 year ago
Envy you your Chile sabbatical (Cerro Tololo?). I've often had to push and pull to get around non-horse racing but telescope building husband to hear and see my racing!
philcoforde More than 1 year ago
Hovdey=MUST READ
Tim More than 1 year ago
This is just a beautifully written article that I enjoyed immensely. I don't want to live at my house any more. I want to live at Jay's house.
Ken Wiener More than 1 year ago
"At least I'm not the oldest thing in her collection." What a great turn of phrase! Mr. Hovdey takes himself down a peg in a most humourous way. Someone asked me what I was laughing about as I was reading it.
AzShowVivor More than 1 year ago
I was on the rail cheering on my favorite Horse at the time called "Hello" in the Swaps Stakes that was won by Free House...I will never forget when i saw this tragic event happen litterally right in front of my eyes...This is the sad part about this great game...After watching him fall and be put down on the track I sat down on a bench crying my eyes out for hours...RIP Hello, you are still a champion in my eyes!
Robert Smith More than 1 year ago
Robert More than 1 year ago
heres hoping no incident like that day mucks up today...i was at belmont park for 1990 breeders cup when GO FOR WAND suffered that catistrophic injury...the party went to a funeral in a new york minute...GO ORB AND SHUG
Jeffrey More than 1 year ago
Prairie Bayou was a gelding. For that mistake you get a B+ for the column. Nice job.
JayHovdey More than 1 year ago
Yes he was, Jeffrey. Good catch and thank you.
Jeffrey More than 1 year ago
Prairie Bayou wasn't around for very long but he was a game horse who had that move that caught everyones eyes. I recall that Belmont vividly. It was a well deserved victory for the connections.
JoyJackson21 More than 1 year ago
First, mad props to Julie Krone. Your winning the Belmont on Colonial Affair is pretty darn awesome! Good for you, that's great! Second, Mike Smith's description of what it must have sounded like to Palace Malice in the Kentucky Derby to hear 19 pairs of thundering hooves combined with a hundred thousand shouting people descending upon him all at once while not being able to see where the danger was coming from (which is what Palace Malice perceived was happening) because of those unfortunate blinkers, was a very eloquent & empathetic statement. I can totally imagine & empathize with Palace Malice's fear when Mike envisioned it for me. It is my hope that Mr. Pletcher has finally learned a lesson in this. He put blinkers on Flower Alley in the 2007 Kentucky Derby & on Palace Malice in 2013's Kentucky Derby, resulting in the same horrible scenario happening to both horses. It lost both Flower Alley & Palace Malice any chance of winning the biggest race of them all - the Kentucky Derby. Please don't put blinkers on the horses in Triple Crown and Breeders' Cup races, where the crowds are extremely large coupled with the field of participants being large & crowded. It is way too terrifying for the horses to not be able to see what or who is approaching them. Give them a level playing field to at least try to win the race. You can do a blinkers experiment in races that have less at stake, and where the crowds will be much smaller. I hope Palace Malice will be able to redeem himself in the Belmont Stakes, run a spectacular race & do his best racing. His performance in the Kentucky Derby was certainly not his fault. Last, reading about Prairie Bayou's final moments made me so sad. Poor Prairie Bayou. I never knew he was a favorite equine friend of Mike Smith's. It must have caused him immeasurable grief to so horribly lose a horse he dearly loved. My condolences to Mike, I know he still feels the loss of his friend. Rest in peace, Prairie Bayou. Good job, your work in life was well done. You are missed by all.
Brandon Layer More than 1 year ago
ESPN classic recently aired the 1993 Belmont. It was very sad watching Prairie Bayou pre race knowing what was about to happen.
Steven Rolf More than 1 year ago
Ya that sucks watching old races that a horse died. I still can't watch a replay of the 2006 Preakness.
Ceil Rock More than 1 year ago
I can't watch Ruffian or Go For Wand.
Mike More than 1 year ago
Yep! Those are the two that I jut can't bear to watch.
not impressed More than 1 year ago
I can watch the races they won. I can't bring myself to watch the ones where they died. Both such fantastic fillies and of which we'll likely never see again.
Debra Medlock More than 1 year ago
Go For Wand is horrific. Cannot watch it. I had one of my horses clip heels and go down on the far turn. Both jockey and horse lay immobile for minutes as I ran the length of the grandstand to get a better view. Owners are not allowed out on the track or I would have been there with her. Fortunately my beloved filly was able to climb soundly to her feet. Jockey spent the night in the hospital. The horrific spill at Charlestown last winter brought such things all back.
Frank More than 1 year ago
I like Mike Smith -- but I still to this day feel he did a cowardly thing with Prairie Bayou by clearly jumping off the horse after he broke down leaving the horse to keep running on making the facture worse. He didn't fall off -- That image is burned into my head of him jumping off and abandoning that horse instead of pulling him up. Great racehorse Prairie Bayou loved that horse.
William More than 1 year ago
It could have falling down both the horse and the jock.... and could be a lot worse ?
Steven Rolf More than 1 year ago
He lost the reigns.
Frank More than 1 year ago
He lost the reigns because the article said right? Yea because people and reporters never lie.
not impressed More than 1 year ago
If you watch the replay, which I did unfortunately several times when they showed the telecast in 1993, it was clear the reins were jerked out of his hands when Prairie Bayou stumbled. You can see the reins toss in the air when PB lurched forward and Mike then lost his balance and off he came. But again, without having been in the saddle it's hard to judge him for that. The injury happened so fast, anyone would have had trouble keeping abreast of him. RIP PB.
Brandon Layer More than 1 year ago
Sadly Prairie Bayou would have had to have been put down either way. Even if Smith did pull him up and stop him. Wouldn't have mattered, the leg was gone with that first bad step. You could tell by how PB was running after the fracture happened. Trying to stop ASAP would have damaged the leg even further as well.
Frank More than 1 year ago
True Brandon. But we will never know -- Smith jumped off -- believe what you want about losing the reigns because a jockey would never say he jumped off to save his neck. Standard protocol is you try to pull a horse up using good judgment.
Ann Ferland More than 1 year ago
It is 'reins' that control horses. 'Reigns' are something that kings and queens, and, by extension, other people in charge, enjoy - same root as regnal, regent, etc.