10/16/2014 2:34PM

Hovdey: McCarron forced to teach hard lessons

Churchill Downs/Reed Palmer Photography
Juan Saez became the 153rd jockey fatality since records were first kept, in 1940, by the Jockeys' Guild.

It’s one thing to stand at arm’s length and contemplate the horror of last Tuesday afternoon at Indiana Grand Race Course, where the 17-year-old apprentice Juan Saez was killed in a race worth $34,000.

It is quite another, though, to wake up the next morning and confront a room full of young Juan Saez wannabes, all of them longing to live the life of a professional jockey in spite of the dangers once again screaming at them from the headlines.

“I’m pretty upset about something, and I’m going to show you what it is,” began retired Hall of Fame jockey Chris McCarron as he convened his class at the North American Racing Academy in Lexington, Ky. “Someone has lost their life for the sake of the profession.”

McCarron proceeded to show his students the video of the Saez accident, which occurred without warning when Saez’s horse, the 4-year-old Montezuma Express, appeared to clip the heels of another horse while racing on the far turn of the six-furlong optional claimer. Saez, a graduate of the Laffit Pincay Jockey School in Panama, won 89 races in a U.S. career that began last June and included the riding title at the Ellis Park meet.

“They were visibly saddened, of course,” McCarron said of his students. “There were a lot of concerned faces in the room. But I’m not there to sugarcoat or hide anything from them.”

McCarron has had a lot of material lately with which to work. In recent weeks, there have been a series of well-known riders injured to varying degrees in accidents during the post parade, the starting gate, and in the heat of the race itself.

:: Click here to purchase a copy of “Long Rein: Tales from the World of Horse Racing,” a collection of columns and features by Jay Hovdey

While a trailing horse was fatally injured in the chain reaction triggered by the Saez accident, Montezuma Express escaped without serious damage. This is a sight that tends to confound the racing fan with a visual disconnect – the horse is loping away, footloose and fancy-free, but the rider is down, terrifyingly still.

To hear experienced riders tell it, horses are clipping heels all the time during a race. This is because American racing is conducted primarily on ovals of a mile or less, and the American style of riding is tight. Jockeys have it driven into their heads at a young age that loss of ground is a cardinal offense. They learn to measure in inches how close they can ride to the opposition, and sometimes they get it wrong.

“It doesn’t happen as often on the turf because horses are flat-shod, wearing Queens Plate shoes,” McCarron said. “It is the toe grabs on the shoes worn for dirt racing that make for a greater chance that a horse could go down clipping heels, and it stands to reason. If the shoe grabs something and holds for only a split second, that interruption in the stride can be enough to cause a fall.”

McCarron has been campaigning for years for the elimination of the cleat, or toe grab, on the front of racing plates, which many trainers believe provides for better traction. There have been restrictions in place – in California, for instance, a toe grab can be no higher than four millimeters – but the fact that they are allowed at all increases the chances that a routine clipping of heels might result in a fall, in McCarron’s view.

“There are other reasons other than toe grabs that a horse will stumble or fall when they’ve clipped heels, just as there are a number of circumstances that lead to horses clipping heels at all,” McCarron said. “Sometimes it’s reckless riding, sometimes it’s careless riding.”

And sometimes it’s the view.

“I was told by someone familiar with Indiana Grand that at that point, at that time of day, jockeys have difficulty with the sun in their eyes,” McCarron said. “There are many racetracks around the country where we experience that problem. If your goggles have any scratches on them whatsoever, the scratches will refract the sunlight, and it’s very difficult to see where you’re going.

“From watching the replay, I’m noticing that Juan did not react at all when the horse in front of him is coming back to him in the middle of the turn,” McCarron said. “There’s no standing up on his part, no checking. It was just getting closer, closer, and then down. I will bet anything that he lost sight for a brief period of time.”

In a career of 28 years, 34,240 mounts, and 7,141 wins at the top of the game, McCarron counts himself fortunate that he never witnessed a fellow rider pay the ultimate price. There have been 153 riding fatalities documented by The Jockeys’ Guild since it started keeping track in 1940.

In October 1988, McCarron was in California, riding at Santa Anita, when Mike Venezia was killed at Belmont Park. In January 1975, McCarron was still in Maryland, fresh off his championship apprentice season, when Alvaro Pineda was killed in the starting gate at Santa Anita. On Oct. 14, 2014, when apprentice Juan Saez lost his life on the far turn at Indiana Grand, McCarron was at home in Kentucky grading quiz papers for his class of future jockeys.

“Whenever there’s such an incident, I’m there to teach them why I think it happened and how it maybe could have been prevented,” McCarron said. “They need to know – this is the worst part of the game.”

slewof damascus More than 1 year ago
I have asked if youth and inexperience could have played a part in this tragic accident (and others like it involving young riders)? How young is too young? We have 16yo apprentices, who are not allowed to drive a motor vehicle without an adult present in the car. This is not about blame, but there are pressures upon young riders to ride early in case they can't make the weight later. Should we limit the number of rides a terribly young jockey can book in a given day? What about stringent film review sessions after each riding day? I, for one, would be willing to accept the extra take-out % to get something like this in-place. I'd imagine that many retired jockeys or current jocks, for that matter, would be willing to give their [salaried] time to such a worthwhile endeavor. Am I off-base here, Jay or anyone?
Kevin Miller More than 1 year ago
The other jockeys in the article were older men. I think you are way off base.
Pagani Zonda More than 1 year ago
Makes you appreciate the jocks who navigate the 2mile Melbourne cup with 25 runners.
nicholas More than 1 year ago
such a tragedy--prayers and sincere condolences to the Saez family---RIP ---i remember mike venezia--he rode a stakes horse for mary cotter named if winter comes that i used to hot walk when i was in high school---he was such a nice man always brought breakfast to the barn after he rode her--everyone was so distraught after he passed---RIP Mike take Saez under your wing up there
nick More than 1 year ago
I rode a little 100 races back in 1975 and won 3. Thats all the time I could make the weight. It is an extremely dangerous way to make a living. And for some odd reason you have the death of a young talented apprentice and other deaths and wheel chair bound Ron Turcotte's of the game. And there are other freak instances of Pat Day who rode thousands of races without a scratch. It will always be a death defying act of riding races. There needs to be safety measures put in place for both jocks and horses. Federal guidelines for meds, toe grabs, softer whips,etc... My sympathy goes out to the Saez family.
Dee Englehart More than 1 year ago
It's good he isn't sugar coating it for them because they need to know just how dangerous a jockey's job really is. It's one thing to tell them about what happened but when you show them, it makes it real for them. I applaud Chris for how he chose to educate them about what can happen on a racetrack.
Scott Scheib More than 1 year ago
it just shows how dangerous it is being a jock, and how fearless they can be at times. Handicappers are easy to call out "bad rides" but simply have no comprehension of the skill, talent and courage it requires to stay on an animal in horse traffic, but to time a win at the last second. I get frustrated with rides from time to time, but i respect these stellar athletes. I am saddened this young man's life was cut short. It was, with some consolation, while he was doing something he loved and was very good at in a fairly short life.
David More than 1 year ago
very inappropriate to insert a link to purchase a Jay Hovdey book in the middle of this sad article, but anything for a buck huh Jay.
Paul Ferg More than 1 year ago
take a hike David
rahman Williams More than 1 year ago
I sort of agree with you
Sue Macphee-Gray More than 1 year ago
Two women jockeys (I think in Australia) have passed away, too, in the past several days. Rest in peace Luis.... Maybe there are some things they'll change. Maybe.
Sue Macphee-Gray More than 1 year ago
So sorry, Juan. Sorry, I was thinking of the brother.
Torrie Ann Needham More than 1 year ago
No one better to listen to than, Chris. He knows what he teaches.
mikey More than 1 year ago
He learned from one of the best ever.Chris got him in place to be a great one.Shame this had to happen.Guess the man upstairs had another plan.RIP you will be missed.
Mike B More than 1 year ago
It was actually Laffit Pincay, but still, a horrible loss