01/22/2015 3:32PM

Hovdey: Fiddling with rules burns jockeys' image

Email

The Jockeys’ Guild should have had a pretty good week.

On Saturday night at Gulfstream Park, guild members Javier Castellano and Drayden Van Dyke put a polished image on display in graceful, heartfelt acceptances of their Eclipse Awards for the 2014 season.

On Monday, the guild’s directors and available members assembled in Florida to do their annual business while taking advantage of the afterglow from Eclipse Awards festivities. They were rewarded with a handsome turnout of industry celebrities, including past guild presidents Jerry Bailey and Chris McCarron.

That same night, on the nationally syndicated broadcast of “Jeopardy!,” the $800 Double Jeopardy question under the category of “Labor” was: “Founding members of their guild, the J.G., include Eddie Arcaro, Johnny Longden and John Pollard.” The answer was, “What is the Jockeys’ Guild?” And somebody got it right.

Unfortunately, the only jockey news to make headlines from Sunday morning on was the Roman Chapa story from Sam Houston Race Park and his suspension by Texas racing authorities pending investigations into Chapa’s alleged possession of an electrical device in a race Saturday night. Chapa, a two-time loser on similar charges from his past, is a member in good standing of the Jockeys’ Guild.

The concept of using an electrical shock to terrify a racehorse into a burst of forward energy is vomit-inducing from any number of angles, just as it is absurd that jockeys come up with the idea on their own. The fact that it has been practiced for decades, with a wink here and a nod there, is one of those dirty secrets that racetrackers share to their everlasting shame. Every jockey will have a buzzer story, whether they’ve used one in the morning or afternoon, or refuse to go along and jeopardize their business.

The guild issued a predictably measured statement in the wake of the Chapa story that tried to have it both ways, vowing to “insure that all its members receive due process in the event they face charges for improper conduct,” while condemning “the use of any devices that affect the performance of any horse.”

If this sounds like coming down on the side of motherhood and apple pie, good call. But like any professional group, the guild is loath to hang a member out to dry, at least until he or she saws off the limb (mixed metaphor duly noted). Terry Meyocks, the guild’s national manager, was somewhat more pointed, however, when asked what advice he would give a jockey who was given the choice of using a buzzer or losing a mount.

“Say no,” Meyocks said. “You’ve got to say no. I can’t do it. I won’t do it. Pick up the phone, call the TRPB integrity hotline and tell them what happened because believe me, if you get caught and stand to lose your license, or maybe even go to jail, that trainer won’t be there for you.”

Of course, it’s not as simple as that. But if the guild backs whistle-blowing members to the hilt, loudly and in public, the Chapa incident might be one of those watershed moments that inspires a fundamental shift in racing culture.

Forgive riders, however, if they suffer from a number of mixed messages, some of them highlighted at the Guild Assembly this week.

For instance, as the menu of exotic bets expands at the same pace as concerns for animal abuse, jockeys would like to know just how hard they are supposed to ride for fifth place in a Super High Five race when the difference between purse placings amounts to about a hundred bucks, and their horse might be dead tired and far behind the winner.

In an era of technological advancements in sports equipment and testing, with helmet and vest designs improving by leaps and bounds, riders and their representatives are right to wonder why state racing commissions are so reluctant to require such protective gear as part of a racetrack’s license application. Likewise other sensible, precautionary measures, most of them urged by the accreditation process of the NTRA’s Safety and Integrity Alliance.

“If a racetrack can’t do prerace exams at racetracks, they shouldn’t get licensed,” Meyocks said. “If you can’t monitor shockwave therapy, a track shouldn’t get licensed. If you don’t have paramedics on site, they shouldn’t get licensed. These should be very basic concerns of commissions.”

Ah, but that would be preventive medicine, and everyone knows how that goes down. Meyocks can point to the 154 jockey fatalities since 1940 and the 71 riders who currently qualify as permanently disabled as reasons enough to continue banging on the drum for more emphasis on safety measures. Juan Saez, a promising apprentice killed at Indiana Grand last October, was not officially honored at the Eclipse Awards but mentioned more than once, especially by fellow apprentice Van Dyke.

“Why are we doing this? All this emphasis on better helmets, vests, safety reins, rails?” Meyocks said. “It benefits everybody if we can prevent riders from being killed or paralyzed. It’s very cost-prohibitive to have the ontrack accident policies. But if we work together to reduce these incidents, it can be beneficial to everyone.”

So, there’s the challenge. Bad news like the Chapa story can be marginalized with a preponderance of swift, positive action. To prevent considerably worse news like the death of Saez requires persistent pressure and creative compromise from groups like the Jockeys’ Guild and the sport’s other major players. Meyocks is hopeful but realistic.

“The blinkers are on in a lot of cases,” he said. “We need to open up the blinkers.”

Hail No More than 1 year ago
"jockeys would like to know just how hard they are supposed to ride for fifth place in a Super High Five" That question highlights the absurdity of the wagering menu...WPS, exacta and trifecta isn't enough, at ridiculous takeout rates?
reainusa More than 1 year ago
While I hale tracks introducing 50cent wagers to help protect my meager bankroll; I also think they don't want to offend bigger money with reduced payouts. Boris low's (correct name??) 15k wager taking down a multi-million dollar pool this past summer comes to mind.
Hail No More than 1 year ago
I was talking about individual race(s). Multi-race wagers are fine, but 2PK 5s and a PK6 on a card? That's too much, how about one pik5 or pik6 with the lower takeout, that would increase handle 3 fold, at least. Also, nothing wrong with .50cent wagers, or even the .10cent minimums, it gives the illusion that bettors have a chance at a big score, but the pik6, with people putting upwards of 5 or 10 thou tiks, is an illusion, too, making people think they have it "covered" which is not always the case, as stats point out. Mr Borislow, won a great pool, on only a 15thou tik, was it? How many similarly priced tiks did he (and other bettors) place that did not win. When betting that kind of tik, in the thous, they'd have to have a high% winning those wagers, to break even.
Hail No More than 1 year ago
PS, although Borislow was an exception, as the payout was so huge, but you know 15mil is not the norm :)
Mel More than 1 year ago
Really appreciate your outstanding articles Jay!!! As someone noted below, you seem to get better and better. Tough task to accomplish when you are already the best Turf Writer in America!!
Hail No More than 1 year ago
I think we have a couple of awesome writers, and their name's begin with "H" :) But Hovdey rocks!
Cover2 More than 1 year ago
The " Pumper " used one, he used to pitch it infield when done. SA w/ turf course ? Hol no TC or DMR ...... J L the man
Judith Van Doren More than 1 year ago
This article should be read by all who are involved with rules. Very to the point, and informative to those who are not aware of improvements; improvements are probably in the offering as time goes by, but most not advised of what they are and where they can be obtained. Seems counter-productive to complain about injuries and deaths to horses and not include jockeys in with the preventative measures.
kingsailor2 More than 1 year ago
Mr. Hovdey -- am enjoying your articles so much; they seem to get better all the time. When the contestant answered the Jeopardy question on the Jockey Guild, audible gasp from others that he had gotten it right.
_______________________ _________________________ More than 1 year ago
Another Chris McErlean - Penn National track that wont do a thing to kick out the wrong people but as soon as a vet bad mouths Penn National, they try to ban her for 5 years! Yet another reason why no one supports Penn Gaming. He should NEVER be allowed on the grounds of SHRP due to cheating but Chris McErlean isn't a man and wont enforce that Just another dent in the tarnished image of Penn Gaming
Mike R More than 1 year ago
They had cancel after 5 races last night at Penn gamings track Sam Houston because the lights went out. I wonder if they paid their light bill late?
Pete Sundar More than 1 year ago
Another terrific article by Hovdey ! Hopefully the PETA haters will take note. PETA highlighted the preponderance of Roman Chapa to cheat in their submission to the Kentucky racing Commission in their enquiry of Asmussen. As can be expected by that cesspool of mediocrity, that Kentucky racing has become...they did not even bother to interview Chapa. Two days later, the emboldened Chapa with an assist by the utter incompetence of the lords of American racing.. decided to cheat in "broad daylight". NYRA has the same report submitted by PETA on Asmussen. It will be interesting to see how they rule on Asmussen in the coming weeks...
electricderby More than 1 year ago
So why was there never an explanation for this bizarre video captured after the Ku Derby of 1995? No legitimate excuse for what was seen can be found, anywhere. Maybe Chapa figured , if it was good enough for them , why not me? See for yourself. https://tinyurl.com/pnr76ex
Randy Baker More than 1 year ago
Most fans are also unaware of shockwave therapy use .It is used to speed healing but also temporarily numbs pain (like bowed tendons)when given pre-race.How do you test for that?Again sadly I know.
cherney19 More than 1 year ago
This jockey should have been banned for life after the first time he got caught. If he isn't banned for life this time shame on racing. If you want to get fans back, this must be stopped and the jockeys have to be banned for life.