04/14/2016 12:20PM

Hovdey: Bells toll for once-great San Juan Capistrano


If this were a merciful world, and let’s pretend that it is, that would have been the final running of the San Juan Capistrano last Sunday at Santa Anita Park. The race needs to be put out of its misery. Devalued, downgraded, and roundly ignored, what was once the aesthetic pinnacle of West Coast grass racing has become a ghost, a remnant, whatever it is that comes after an afterthought.

Whoever let the San Juan get to this point should be ashamed, but the suspects are many. American breeders stopped breeding 1 3/4-mile horses who like the grass. European owners stopped sending their third- or fourth-best runners to Southern California trainers. Local racing programs contracted, and purses congealed around main-track racing, providing little incentive to ship westward for even the most historic turf events. And never forget the closing of Hollywood Park. Just about everything wrong can be blamed to some degree on the closing of Hollywood Park.

Over the past few years, the following grass stakes open to all comers were eliminated from the Southern California schedule: the San Luis Obispo, the Jim Murray, the Sunset, and the John Henry, formerly the Oak Tree Invitational. Also getting the ax were the Santa Barbara, the Beverly Hills, and the original Yellow Ribbon, all staples of the female turf menu.

With such a winnowing, you would think there would be money available to goose up the surviving events. Think again.

California’s top purse in 2015 for an open, graded turf stakes at more than a mile was the Eddie Read, at $400,000, which is not bad unless you have a horse who’s just warming up at the end of nine furlongs. Then, your choices were the Del Mar Handicap or the Hollywood Turf Cup, each at $250,000, or the Whittingham, the San Marcos, and the San Luis Rey, all at $200,000. The 2015 San Juan Capistrano was worth $150,000. This year, the purse was $100,000. There are maiden races in New York worth $100,000.

Apples and oranges, I know. But the apples of the Southern California long-distance turf scene used to be ripe and delicious, and the San Juan was the ultimate prize. Indulge a little history.

Seabiscuit won the San Juan when it was 14 furlongs on dirt. So did Triplicate, owned by Fred Astaire, and Noor, in an epic struggle with Citation.

St. Vincent won the first San Juan on the grass in 1955, defeating Kentucky Derby winner Determine. Olden Times was good enough to win both the 1962 San Juan and the 1964 Metropolitan Mile. The greatest San Juan ever run was John Longden’s last ride in 1966, when he won with George Royal, unless it was the dead-heat between Fiddle Isle and Quicken Tree in 1970, with Horse of the Year Fort Marcy a nose away from a triple-heater.

On and on the San Juan rolled, its purse hitting $400,000, then half a million. Great Communicator bookended 1988 with the San Juan and the Breeders’ Cup Turf. Kotashaan edged Bien Bien on his way to 1993 Horse of the Year. Marlin doubled up the 1997 San Juan and the Arlington Million, while Meteor Storm took the 2004 San Juan, then added the Manhattan on Belmont Day.

That’s the kind of horse you needed to win the San Juan, and the San Juan was that kind of race.

As the fields thinned, the remorseless American Graded Stakes Committee weighed in, and the San Juan tumbled to a Grade 3 event clinging to Grade 1 memories. The minimum purse for a Grade 3 race is $100,000, so that’s where it sits in the Santa Anita stakes universe, a hollow shell of its history.

If last Sunday’s San Juan was the last San Juan, at least it went out on an appropriate note, won by the 8-year-old Chilean stayer Quick Casablanca for owner Pablo Gomez and Hall of Fame trainer Ron McAnally after finishing third in the San Marcos and second in the San Luis Rey. Only Charlie Whittingham won more San Juans than McAnally.

“Yeah, but I’m too old now to win it 14 times,” McAnally said with a laugh, referring to how many Whittingham won.

McAnally’s four San Juans began with John Henry in 1980, the first of his four campaigns as North America’s grass champion. The trainer came back in 1998 with Verne Winchell’s Amerique, then added the globetrotting Interaction in 2013.

“Don’t forget the favorite I scratched,” McAnally reminded.

That was also John Henry, in 1981, when the trainer exercised caution with his emerging star and passed the San Juan, only because the full distance of the race required a brief passage over the muddy main track.

“I wasn’t concerned about the soft turf,” McAnally said. “But the change back and forth over the muddy strip was a concern.”

John Henry ended up being Horse of the Year anyway.

Management was faced with a similar predicament last Sunday – crossing a muddy main strip five-eighths of a mile into the race – so they punted and turned the 2016 San Juan into a 15-furlong excursion, round and round the infield course. If nothing else, it was entertaining, and Quick Casablanca made a move on the final turn for Tyler Baze that would have done any winner proud.

Whether or not the San Juan continues is academic, although it has earned a noble retirement and should be either renamed or dropped. It is not the San Juan of Seabiscuit, Mr. Consistency, Cougar II, Tiller, Exceller, Lemhi Gold, and John Henry. But at least a piece of it still belongs to McAnally, whose public stable has fallen on quiet times.

“I’ve said all along, just give me the horse,” McAnally said. “Our job is to keep them fit and sound and keep them happy. All it takes is the right horse.”

The San Juan Capistrano is 76. McAnally is 83. One of them is still going strong.

Judith Van Doren More than 1 year ago

Was hoping USA was going to have more grass races, with the tracks at Santa Anita and Keeneland.  but the distances do not seem to be l 1/2 or longer from what I have seen.  From the recent 3yr olds I have seen, and a lot that are going to run in KY Derby, they look stronger and more muscled. 
John Murray More than 1 year ago
As I was reading the race chart, my thoughts also.

I prefer to encourage more longer racing on the green for safety, aesthetics and durability of animals, the quality of horse available is no longer there unfortunately.

Gaye Goodwin More than 1 year ago
Thanks in large part to the QH trainers and the "corporate run" racing stables. Quick returns mean speedy sires and it shows.
Cheryl Kleist More than 1 year ago
The quality is there, only it isn't in flat racing.  Instead it is in steeplechase racing and cross country eventing.  I must admit, nothing in riding is more fun for horse or rider 
than cross country.  You have the racing aspect as well as more naturally constructed in
and outs or streams.  The real dirt and turf races longer than 1 1/2 miles thrive in S. America.  That is why so many of their horses do well.  I will never forget Calidoscorpio in the Breeders Cup Marathon.  An older horse 8 or 9 so distant behind the field.  Gryder begged the owners to let him ride.  It was perfect.  What a closer!  Flew past the field and won by several lengths!  Watching him in the Manhattan with a considerable bet on him to win, I was asked if he had lost his riders at 20 lengths behind the field.  I assured my friend that he was going to win the race which no one believed.  Wow what a win!  He is back in South America now breeding little Calidoscorpios.  
Margi Foley More than 1 year ago
The "remorseless" American Graded Stakes Committee INDEED!  In the last several years, they have just about eviscerated the graded turf stakes program in California.  The Eddie Read, which was downgraded to a GII last year, was the last remaining GI turf stake in California run over a mile for open company!  There are NO more!  The only GI turf races California has any more are either run at a flat mile, or are restricted to 3yos.  I can only count six of them left, and of them, I'm not sure that the American Oaks is even going to be run this year.  The other five, by the way, are the Kilroe & Shoemaker Miles, the 1M Matriarch, and the Del Mar Oaks & Hollywood Derby for 3yos.  It's a truly sad state of affairs.

I agree with you, Jay.  I think I would rather see the great San Juan Capistrano completely scrapped than to see it run under the conditions that it lives under now.  And if this year was the last running, you are so right that it couldn't possibly have been more appropriate.......and more emotional.  I was up on the Club House Mezzanine floor, and McAnally chose to come up there to watch the race on the big TV board.  Watching him standing there watching the race and seeing him win it 36 years after John Henry hooked me into this game in the same race gave me chills and brought tears to my eyes.

If this is to be my last memory of the San Juan Capistrano, I welcome it!
Chas More than 1 year ago
It is amazing how turf racing is falling by the waste side out here in California...we have great weather in the winter months and yet the turf racing is far less than in Florida and even the Fair Grounds....
The blame is the owners out here wanting dirt horses and chasing the Derby dream and older stake races; the breeders who in Kentucky care only about dirt breeding; and track owner Frank Stronach,  who could care less about SA compared to GP and Laurel Park, as he does basically a 'hands off' approach to what goes on at SA....
And the current 'clueless' management of Keith Brackpool, who is more interested with 'getting the pretty people who will spend $$$$ just to attend the races' over the racing product...
These turf races should be saved, change the distance say from 1 3/4 to 1 1/2 if needed make them more appealing... 
Gaye Goodwin More than 1 year ago
I disagree. The American Oaks was a very nice race when ti offered $750K and attracted international competition. Shortening the races would only cave to the pressure of those trainers who really don't train classic distance horses, but speedsters that hang on ahead of the other like horses. Why give THEM all the available money? They have enough, already.
Richard Johnson More than 1 year ago
Chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
Rattle Stronachs' cage. With the renewal of the DC International an East West Turf Triple is  a sure winner with a turf race at Gulfstream. 
Thomas McDonough More than 1 year ago
The good news is that it appears as though we will get the International back--and it may even have Grade 2 status if the Maryland and Virginia horseracing interests can get together.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Jay, Seabiscuit won the race t 9 furlongs accoding to wikapedia. I agree with the scenario that the San Juan Capastrano should be ended. Most of the entrants are allowance level horses without the pedigree to go the distance much less 9 furlongs. Good article!
Chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
All anomypottamusses should be ended...
Gaye Goodwin More than 1 year ago
Which is why a South American bred horse won it, and no, he is not an "allowance level" horse.
Sidd Finch More than 1 year ago
I contend that, were it true what the author claims, about Seabiscuit having won the SJC over 14 furlongs on dirt, that they would play that race each day at the start and finish of Del Mar, instead of the Bing Crosby tape.  (owing to its utterly fascinating 1:48 2/5 duration)

It would in turn be listed as the single most scintillating achievement in the history of American racing (perhaps displacing Secretariat's Belmont in that regard).

Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Seabiscuit won the SJC at 1 1/8 miles on dirt. 
Laura More than 1 year ago
McAnally needs the horses, Jack Van Berg needs the big horses, why don't they get them? it's not like they don't want to work, and they've forgotten more about training than most will ever know, and still know more than most, so why don't the big owners send their prospects to them anymore? I just don't get it...I mean, Baffert and Pletcher don't have unlimited stalls, they can't take every horse, give the older guys a chance!
Chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
Because neither will hop a horse.
Eleanor Sniegowski More than 1 year ago
I think Jack may have found the fountain of youth juice at the current Oak Lawn meeting.Has more winners there than 5 years of california.
Gaye Goodwin More than 1 year ago
yes, but who swoops in year after year to take the big money three year old races? The same trainers he left behind in CA