Updated on 01/07/2013 1:40PM

Eclipse Awards: Fort Larned, I'll Have Another, Wise Dan Horse of the Year finalists

Email
Tom Keyser
Wise Dan is an Eclipse finalist in three categories: Turf Male, Older Male, and Horse of the Year.

Wise Dan, who completed his 2012 campaign with a victory in the Breeders’ Cup Mile, emerged as the favorite to be named Horse of the Year when finalists for all 17 Eclipse Award divisions were announced on Saturday by the National Thoroughbred Racing Association, which co-sponsors the awards along with Daily Racing Form and the National Turf Writers and Broadcasters Association.

Wise Dan is one of three finalists for Horse of the Year, along with Fort Larned, the Breeders’ Cup Classic winner, and the 3-year-old I’ll Have Another, who won the Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes. The glaring omission from that list is Little Mike, the Breeders’ Cup Turf winner, who is a rival with Wise Dan for two divisional awards – older male and male turf – but failed to earn enough first-place votes to be a finalist for Horse of the Year.

Fort Larned, Little Mike, and Wise Dan are the three finalists for older male. The surprise is that Little Mike, who won all of his races on turf, made that list, knocking out Game On Dude, who was considered the divisional leader prior to his poor performance as the favorite in the Breeders’ Cup Classic.

The male turf category, in which Little Mike and Wise Dan also are finalists, has Point of Entry as its third finalist, the expected outcome in what was considered one of the strongest divisions in 2012.

If Wise Dan were to capture Horse of the Year, and divisional titles for male turf and older male, he would be the first horse to win those three Eclipse Awards in the same year since John Henry in 1981. Forego was Horse of the Year, champion sprinter, and champion older horse in 1974. Secretariat was Horse of the Year, champion 3-year-old, and champion turf horse in 1973.

I’ll Have Another, the other finalist for Horse of the Year, is the overwhelming favorite to be named champion 3-year-old male, a category whose finalists also include Bodemeister, the runner-up to I’ll Have Another in both the Derby and Preakness, and Union Rags, the Belmont Stakes winner. None of the three ran after the Triple Crown and all are retired.

Voters from the three organizations were required to turn in their ballots by Thursday. On Saturday, the three horses or individuals who received the most first-place votes in their respective divisions were announced as the finalists. The winners will be announced at the 42nd annual Eclipse Awards dinner on Jan. 19 at Gulfstream Park.

There were 272 eligible voters, of whom 254 submitted ballots.

The voters had a few surprises, most notably not ranking Little Mike among the top three for Horse of the Year. Also, Morton Fink, the owner and breeder of Wise Dan, and Charlie Lopresti, who trains Wise Dan, failed to be named finalists in their divisions, as voters largely adhered to the year-end earnings lists to glean finalists in those categories.

The three finalists for owner are Sheikh Mohammed’s Godolphin Racing, which led the earnings list with the Dubai World Cup card included; Midwest Thoroughbreds, which led in North American purse earnings; and Paul Reddam’s Reddam Racing, which owned I’ll Have Another.

The finalists for breeder are Frank Stronach’s Adena Springs, Sheikh Mohammed’s Darley, and Brereton C. Jones, who were the top three in that category in purse earnings nationally in 2012.

Trainers Bob Baffert and Todd Pletcher, both of whom have won Eclipse Awards in the past, are finalists again this year along with Dale Romans, who had the best year of his career and is considered a slight favorite. Pletcher and Baffert were one-two nationally in earnings, with Romans fourth, behind Steve Asmussen.

Wise Dan’s jockey, John Velazquez, avoided a complete shutout for humans connected to the horse. He is a finalist for champion jockey along with fellow Eastern riders Javier Castellano and Ramon Dominguez. Those riders were the top three nationally in purse earnings.

Voters also put great weight behind the Breeders’ Cup. Of the 10 divisions for horses on the flat, eight include at least one Breeders’ Cup winner among their finalists, with older male being made up entirely of Breeders’ Cup winners, and male turf including two Breeders’ Cup winners.

There also are two Breeders’ Cup winners as finalists for both older female and female sprinter, with Groupie Doll, the winner of the Breeders’ Cup Filly and Mare Sprint, a finalist in both divisions.

Groupie Doll is a heavy favorite in the female sprint category, where her rivals are the 3-year-old Contested and Mizdirection, the winner of the Breeders’ Cup Turf Sprint.

Royal Delta, who successfully defended her title in the Breeders’ Cup Ladies’ Classic, is favored over Groupie Doll in the older female category, whose other finalist is Include Me Out.

The unbeaten Shanghai Bobby, who won the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile, is an overwhelming favorite to be named champion 2-year-old male over Uncaptured and Violence. Both Shanghai Bobby and Violence are trained by Pletcher.

Beholder is favored in the 2-year-old filly category against Dreaming of Julia and Executiveprivilege, both of whom Beholder defeated in the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile Fillies.

Zagora emerged as the favorite to be named champion female turf horse when she won that group’s Breeders’ Cup race, the Filly and Mare Turf. The other finalists in that division are Marketing Mix and Tapitsfly.

Trinniberg is favored to parlay a victory in the Breeders’ Cup Sprint into the male sprint title, where his fellow finalists are Shackleford and The Lumber Guy.

One of the closest calls could be for champion 3-year-old filly, in which My Miss Aurelia and Questing are perceived as the two leading contenders, yet the third finalist is the Kentucky Oaks winner, Believe You Can. Contested failed to make the top three.

Steeplechase is also seen as toss-up, between Demonstrative and Pierrot Lunaire. Divine Fortune is the third finalist.

Jose Montano, Irad Ortiz Jr. – the rider of Questing – and Angel Suarez are the finalists for champion apprentice jockey, a category that the three voting blocs have debated dropping in recent years. Ortiz was an apprentice for all of one month in 2012.

2012 Eclipse Awards finalists
Horse of the Year
Fort Larned, I’ll Have Another, Wise Dan

2-Year-Old Male
Shanghai Bobby, Uncaptured, Violence

2-Year-Old Female
Beholder, Dreaming of Julia, Executiveprivilege

3-Year-Old Male
Bodemeister, I’ll Have Another, Union Rags

3-Year-Old Female
Believe You Can, My Miss Aurelia, Questing

Older Male
Fort Larned, Little Mike, Wise Dan

Older Female
Groupie Doll, Include Me Out, Royal Delta

Male Sprinter
The Lumber Guy, Shackleford, Trinniberg

Female Sprinter
Contested, Groupie Doll, Mizdirection

Turf Male
Little Mike, Point of Entry, Wise Dan

Turf Female
Marketing Mix, Tapitsfly, Zagora,

Steeplechase
Demonstrative, Divine Fortune, Pierrot Lunaire

Owner
Godolphin Racing, Midwest Thoroughbreds, Reddam Racing

Breeder
Adena Springs, Darley, Brereton C. Jones

Trainer
Bob Baffert, Todd Pletcher, Dale Romans

Jockey
Javier Castellano, Ramon Dominguez, John Velazquez

Apprentice Jockey
Jose Montano, Irad Ortiz Jr., Angel Suarez

B More than 1 year ago
I'll Have Another, though it will probably go to Wise Dan, which would be one of the weakest HOY ever. At least IHA was unbeaten and won 2/3rd's of the TC, which to me beats a grass miler. Shanghai Bobby obviously, but doubt he has a TC future. Have been a big Executive Privilege fan, but Beholder just might be better. I'll Have Another hands down. I guess Questing. Can't believe Little Mike is a candidate in this category over Game On Dude. I'll go with Wise Dan. Royal Delta can't lose. Trinniberg, but no one really stood out in this category. Who else... Groupie Doll. Think Point of Entry is the best horse here, but BC killed his chances. I'll pick Little Mike in tough category. Zagora, but why can't voters have a choice to say no winner when there is no true stand out? Demonstrative
Advance Plumbing More than 1 year ago
Trainer of yr Dale Romans for his work with Little Mike. HOY for Fort Larned classic winner, distance horse. Wise Dan Older male. Any questions?
John Howland More than 1 year ago
If Fort Larned is HOY,how can he not be Older Male?
ENAMMELD More than 1 year ago
It seems only fitting that the two top awards be split between the two. Wise Dan, I believe is the better horse, as evidenced by his photo loss to Ron The Greek at a time when RTG was at the top of his game. Fort Larned had a very good year topped off by a magnificant BCC run. It can be argued that distance gives it to FL, however it's hard to get by the fact Wise Dan is an exceptional horse and arguably second best to only Franel, I'm not quite sure about that. I'l catch a lot of flak that last part but this is a very strong, fast, horse who I have a hard time imagining anyone running away from at a mile on turf on any course.
not impressed More than 1 year ago
It's voiting lists like the above that really offer no reason for me to follow horse racing. they ignore the horses who deserve award and award others off one performance. I don't get it. This is like a laughing stock of lists all the way around, so much so I won't even watch the eclipse awards. Not worth doing so.
BBT More than 1 year ago
You do realize that the list above is based on the votes that have already been cast? ALL of the horses were originally available to be voted on, the list above are the 3 horses in each category who received the most votes out of ALL of the horses.
B More than 1 year ago
I think 2012 was a weak year for thoroughbreds, but other than Game on Dude, who is missing from these lists that are better?!
Ann Maree More than 1 year ago
If you are counting only 2012 accomplishments, Wise Dan did not win on all three surfaces....his dirt try he lost, the Stephen Foster. In every write up about him, the statement that he is versatile by winning on all three surfaces (at least in 2012) is incorrect. I know there are no specific criteria for HOY, but, HOY should IMHO represent more than a basic miler on turf! 5 months does not a year make? I believe there are examples of past HOY that raced only 5 months. Think of it this way: if IHA had raced 8 times, and still won only the 4 races,(3 G1s, 4 graded stakes, and two Triple Crown races) I don't think there would have been any question that he gets the nod for HOY. It does show how far we have fallen, in that the Eclipse voters have to parse horses that have won as few as 1 Grade 1, or even 2 or 3 G1s for honors.
ENAMMELD More than 1 year ago
Wise Dan's photo loss to Ron The Greek at a time when RTG was at the top of his game and arguably the best dirt horse at that particular time, added to the fact WD got a horrible trip. That along with the fact WD retained his form all year is probably why they say with much truthfulness, he can run well on dirt, and is the best, most consistent horse.
Ann Maree More than 1 year ago
The biggest glaring omission is LADY OF SHAMROCK! What a joke! She wins 2 grade 1s, wins 4 stakes, misses another G2 by a nose. She outshone the others in her categories. Amazing.
Kyle Stasierowski More than 1 year ago
Dear Mr. Privman, In my opinion they have the wrong top 3 finalists for Horse of the Year. I say this because in my opinion the top 3 finalists for Horse of the Year should've been: Fort Larned, Royal Delta, and Wise Dan. Not Fort Larned, I'll Have Another, and Wise Dan. The reason I say this is because this is for Horse of the Year, not Horse of Five Months which is exactly the length of time that I'll Have Another raced. Sincerely, Kyle Stasierowski 28-year-old loyal TVG viewer, HRTV Live Feed viewer, and DRF FaceBook friend and Twitter follower from Alden, New York
not impressed More than 1 year ago
Royal Delta likely lost support for HOTY when she lost her first two starts of 2012 and rather resoundingly. May not be the reason, but voters have quabbled about less.
Mike Bilinskas More than 1 year ago
Fort Larned should be HOY ran against the top horses on a number of occasion and defeated them, Wise Dan ran in mile turf races where he got perfect setups, they had a shot to go in the classic but ducked em again
chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
Romans' small string won South, North, Midwest n West. No Trainer tops him this year, none.
Barbara Bowen More than 1 year ago
Actually Baffert objectively tops him in just about every category - including a dominating earnings per start stat and more Gr. 1 wins than any other trainer, and second (to prolific Pletcher) in graded victories, and you know what? Baffert won from California to New York to Kentucky to Arkansas. But Dale had a career year and is flavor du hour with writers, so he'll win.
Amy Hurley More than 1 year ago
Thanks for pointing this out, Barbara. I didn't realize that. But, big Baffert fan that I am, I still have to give the Eclipse to Dale this year.
myjockwon More than 1 year ago
do you call 150 horses a small string he has horses in new york, Gulfstream Park, Palm Meadows,at his training center in Ky, about 50 there he runs at Turfway. where do u get your information.
chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
Just from the PP's.
Ian Phillips More than 1 year ago
wise dan hoy easily since he finished in fron of ft larned only time they met, while giving him weight. case closed.
chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
Romans did all his winning with justa handful and they're all safe in layup or just getting back into light training. Love Shackleford but now he's ended up head n head with my Little Trinniberg!? Shack shows only 3 races at less than a mile... 2 races from 2009 and that Gr2 at Churchill in May. I don't get it.
Nick Arden More than 1 year ago
Have to go with routers over milers especially one that ducked tougher races. HOtY for me. 1. IHA 2. Royal Delta 3. Fort Larned
ghost2_ More than 1 year ago
And you probably think sprinters really stink, I suppose.
Jock More than 1 year ago
I think that Royal Delta deserves Horse of the year by her consecitive wins in the Ladies Classic. How can they even consider Wise Dan who had to run a mile race to win?
dan More than 1 year ago
Are you kidding me? Wise Dan has won on every surface. If he didn't lose by a neck to Ron The Greek in the Stephen Foster there would be no discussion... Yes it's impressive Royal Delta took the ladies classic 2 years in a row, but this isn't an award for "horse of the past two years".
ghost2_ More than 1 year ago
What's wrong with winning a mile race? Nothing at all!
John Howland More than 1 year ago
Little Mike ran in mile races twice last year,favored in both and finished 3rd and 4th.The 4th place finish was in a Gr3.It's a lot tougher to "steal" a mile race.