08/28/2014 12:31PM

Crist: Double Crown title streak could end


As any schoolchild knows, every 3-year-old since 1978 who won both the Kentucky Derby and Preakness failed to win the Belmont Stakes and complete the Triple Crown. But did you know there’s an even longer streak regarding the winners of the first two legs of the Triple Crown?

Since the Eclipse Awards began in 1971 through last year, 16 horses have won the Derby and Preakness – and every single one of them won the Eclipse Award as champion 3-year-old: Canonero II (1971), Secretariat (1973), Seattle Slew (1977), Affirmed (1978), Spectacular Bid (1979), Pleasant Colony (1981), Alysheba (1987), Sunday Silence (1989), Silver Charm (1997), Real Quiet (1998), Charismatic (1999), War Emblem (2001), Funny Cide (2003), Smarty Jones (2004), Big Brown (2007), I’ll Have Another (2012) and ... wait, not so fast on adding California Chrome (2014) to the list.

After Shared Belief’s impressive victory against his elders in the Pacific Classic last Sunday, he inched ahead of the idle California Chrome in the National Thoroughbred Racing Association’s weekly Horse of the Year poll. (Shared Belief and California Chrome are now ranked second and third behind the 7-year-old gelding Wise Dan.)

You have to go back 45 years, before the dawn of the Eclipses, to find a 3-year-old who won the Derby and Preakness but was not acknowledged as the division’s champion: That would be Majestic Prince in 1969. He beat Arts and Letters by a neck in the Derby and by a head in the Preakness, but Arts and Letters beat him by 5 1/2 lengths in the Belmont and then reeled off consecutive victories in the Jim Dandy, Travers, Woodward, and Jockey Club Gold Cup. (He also won the Blue Grass and, in between the Preakness and Belmont, the Met Mile.) Arts and Letters was understandably acclaimed as the champion 3-year-old and Horse of the Year.

It looked as if things might go the same way a couple of times since. Twenty years after Arts and Letters, Easy Goer had a very similar streak after falling short to Sunday Silence in the Derby and Preakness. He was heavily favored to complete the turnaround in the Breeders’ Cup Classic, but then Sunday Silence beat him for the third time in four meetings and was deservedly a nearly unanimous choice.

In 2003, it seemed that Empire Maker had edged ahead of Funny Cide when he beat him in the Belmont, giving him a 2-1 lead in head-to-head meetings and a 3-2 lead in Grade 1 victories. Neither one of them, however, won a race past June, and by the time ballots were due in December, Funny Cide’s Derby and Preakness made it seem to a majority of voters that he had been the more successful 3-year-old and deserved the nod.

The 2004 voting would have been interesting if Birdstone had won the Breeders’ Cup Classic. After denying Smarty Jones’s bid for the Triple Crown by beating him in the Belmont, Birdstone returned to win the Travers. Would a BC Classic victory have pushed him past the Derby-Preakness winner? We’ll never know since he finished seventh, and Smarty Jones was an easy Eclipse winner.

So, the question now is whether Shared Belief can catch up to a Derby-Preakness winner. Let’s say he makes his fourth and final start of an unbeaten 3-year-old season in the BC Classic and wins it, beating California Chrome in their only meeting. Would it be enough? California Chrome would still have a 3-2 lead in Grade 1 wins (Santa Anita Derby, Kentucky Derby, and Preakness vs. Pacific Classic and BC Classic), but Shared Belief’s two big victories would have been against older horses instead of the uninspiring 3-year-olds whom California Chrome was walloping last spring.

Still, winning the Derby and Preakness is a powerful double that tends to look even better in hindsight. The discussion then comes down to accomplishment vs. talent. It’s possible that one could simultaneously believe at season’s end that Shared Belief is the better horse but that California Chrome accomplished more this year.

It would be a fascinating debate if we get that far. Maybe the best part is that this could develop into more than a one-race rivalry: California Chrome is scheduled to race as a 4-year-old, and Shared Belief is a gelding with an unlimited future on the track. These things are always best settled on the racetrack, so here’s hoping.

Robert Clayton More than 1 year ago
The Derby is the Derby.....Its the race every single horseman in the World wants to win and in terms of impact its probably worth 3 Grade One's
Alex Rohrer More than 1 year ago
I think it is very possible that V.E. Day keeps winning. He may prove to be the best 3 yr old this year by winning the classic..
Van Cushny More than 1 year ago
Agreed: Travers, JCGC & BCC should clinch it for VE Day
slewfan More than 1 year ago
No doubt about it, California Chrome is in the lead as hr has 6 consecutive wins, 3 Grade 1s, and all but 1 win not a Graded stakes win. IF Chrome doesn't win another race this year, and Shared Belief wins both Awesome Again AND BCC, then and only then will SB be ahead of CC for Three yr old Eclipse and HOTY.
Pat More than 1 year ago
Think this whole thing is an exercise in mental masturbation. I would be SHOCKED if California Chrome even makes the board against older horses later this year, so that would by necessity make Shared Belief the top three year old in the country. And if Wise Dan sweeps his slate for the rest of the year, he's once again the top horse in the country. So it seems obvious: top three year old will be Shared Belief and Horse of the Year will be Wise Dan. Only possible suspense would be if Shared Belief wins the Breeders Cup, then he wins both three year old and horse of the year. Chrome had a nice run, but he was running against some incredibly weak field in both the Derby and Preakness.
thomas j More than 1 year ago
I agree. I believe California Chrome's weak pedigree will catch up to him later this year.
Jim Pappas More than 1 year ago
every serious horse player knows that the derby set up perfectly for chrome as the pace was pitifully slow. he doesn't stand a chance against real horses and a legitimate pace
Robert Clayton More than 1 year ago
Name some "real horses" Shared Belief has beaten.....He got a setup in the Pacific Classic a 10 claimer could have won off of......And the only "real horse" he has ever beaten is a weary Game on Dude who was sentenced to death by an import 5 claimer that shouldn't have been permitted to even run in a Grade One.....You (and a lot of others) need to stop punishing horses like CC who have tactical speed to make their own trip and more importantly stay out of trouble
Jim Pappas More than 1 year ago
every serious horse player knows that the derby set up perfectly for chrome and that he would win the preakness. right after the derby byer said he would never win the belmont. i don't think he wins another big race again.
charming idiot More than 1 year ago
i had forgotten what a great season easy goer had after the triple crown. most horses are knocked out after running in all 3 but both easy goer and arts and letters thrived on the full schedule.
John Stevelberg More than 1 year ago
Well written, well thought out. My only comment would be to endorse what you basically said "we'll see" !
Lawrence Vaccarelli More than 1 year ago
winning 2/3 of triple crown is huge because your running those races close together ...not one every 8 to 12 weeks...SB is a monster ...but he has to do much more....granted PC sent him on his way...now he needs to follow up....as for WD...he would need to win race at woodbine and win turf mile...even then I think he comes up short ?...maybe not....as for CC ?....what you forgot already what this monster has done ?...good god he missed the triple crown by less than 2 lengths !...talk about short memories...TC trail is grueling...he was not on r & r
Chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
It seems that Crist is leaning toward Shared Belief , which is fine. However, if Wise Dan wins out then he is Horse of the Year once again, deservedly.