- DRF Bets
- Handicapping & PPsHorsemen's ProductsReports
Access past performances
- The Wizard
- DRF Gameplan
- Quick Sheets
- DRF Picks
- Today's Racing Digest
- Key Race Report
- Positive ROI Report
- Moss Pace Figure Reports
- Debut Reports
- WE Handicapping Report
- Clocker Reports
Racing and Wagering InformationTools
- DRF EasyForm PPs
- DRF Classic PDF PPs
- DRF Formulator PPs
- DRF HarnessEye PPs
- DRF Daily Harness Program PPs
- Daily Racing Program PPs
- NewsCategoriesTrack Notes
- StorePast PerformancesHarness PPsPackagesDRF PlusREPORTSPICKS
Crist: Catskill oversteps its boundaries with New York OTB
By Steven Crist
Last June 21, as New York lawmakers hurried toward a summer recess, both houses of the state legislature passed a bill that would give the Catskill Regional Offtrack Betting Corporation the right to operate OTB parlors in New York City.
Last Wednesday, more than five months later, the bill landed on Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s desk. Even if Cuomo does the right thing and vetoes rather than signs it, the fact that such a preposterous piece of legislation has gotten that close to becoming reality is in itself a disgrace, and further evidence of how cynically and shabbily the government treats horse racing in the Empire State.
Under the bill, Catskill OTB would have its “area of operation” redefined to include the five boroughs of New York City. This is a bit like extending the reach of Rhode Island’s state government to include California, Florida, and Texas. This would allow Catskill to set up OTB parlors throughout the city. Its chairman, Donald Groth, said in June that he hoped to have one parlor in each borough to start and eventually grow the total to at least 20 throughout the city. He even thought his new parlors could be booking bets by this past July, in time for the Saratoga meeting.
Why Catskill should take over offtrack betting in New York City – as opposed to any of the state’s other OTB’s, the tracks, the state itself or, for that matter, your brother-in-law – is not addressed in the bill.
When New York City OTB shuttered its parlors amid bankruptcy in 2010, its business was quickly absorbed by other (mostly online) entities. No one has seriously proposed bringing back NYCOTB, which did little except extract money from the racing industry to fund political patronage jobs for almost four decades.
Resuscitating NYCOTB under the leadership of Catskill – best-known as the operation whose security was so lax that it was home to the Fix Six scandal at the 2002 Breeders’ Cup – is obviously a non-starter. So how did it pass both houses of the state legislature? According to some Albany insiders, the measure was portrayed to lawmakers as a pro-labor bill that might help them court union support in the fall elections. With time running out on the vacation clock, the legislators signed off on a bill it is difficult to believe many had read or understood.
Now this unexploded shell sits on the governor’s desk, where one can only hope it is not signed into law by accident or as part of a trade for a bigger fish. If it is enacted, it will make a sham of Cuomo’s stated intention to overhaul and improve the racing industry. Part of that overhaul was supposed to include moving forward with long-stalled plans for the New York Racing Association to set up a few teletheaters in New York City, the only sensible deployment of brick-and-mortar betting facilities in the city in the online era. For Cuomo instead to cede that operation to Catskill OTB would be an embrace of a discredited OTB system that bears a large share of responsibility for the sport’s decline.
As the political blogger Tom Noonan wrote this week, “In a logical world, one would think that placing OTB’s in New York City would be part of the comprehensive review of racing that the Governor has indicated will take place under his leadership. Since the Legislature approved Cuomo’s takeover of racing with just one dissenting vote, logic would also dictate that the Legislature thinks any significant changes in the betting landscape would await that review, and that the Catskill OTB bill could wait. Or does it just come down to the same craven political considerations with the attendant patronage that sank the former NYC OTB, with the Governor acquiescing while we do our Christmas shopping?”
Perhaps the matter will come up for discussion next Wednesday at the first board meeting of the “new” New York Racing Association, which Cuomo forced under his control in June for at least the next three years. It also will be the first NYRA board meeting chaired by David Skorton, who has not spoken publicly in his new role since Cuomo appointed him to the post Oct. 18.
Skorton, president of Cornell University, is a widely respected academic administrator but has no known experience in or views about racing, and appears to have a day or two a month to devote to his new post. It will be interesting to see if he has an opinion on the Catskill bill and how quick a study he has been about the organization he will now lead. You can see for yourself: The meeting will be open to the public and broadcast live on NYRA’s website.
I think you should open otb in the city because my mom work there
The only way to revive horse racing in New York City is to make it attractive to young urban professsionals with new facilities, a hip atmosphere and good racing. Currently, the facilities (other than Saratoga) stink, literally and figuratively, the crowd is borderline homeless people and the racing is pitiful. This is the result of years of corruption and mismanagment. Slots improve the purses but otherwise detract from the racing and the crowd. Three cheers to any plan that turns it upside down whether the old dogs like it or not. I'll take a Cornell president, a govenenor and entreprenuers from the Catskills over what we had. In the era of simulcasting and on-line gambling, you don't need live tracks everywhere and NY tracks could easily scale back or disappear. Whoever thought the Meadowlands would be dark for months at a time? Wake up, and get on board with new blood that smells the money.
With all the on line way's to bet today there is no need for OTB'S. OTB'S were dirty place's with rude worker's .The day's for them is in the past.OTB WAS THE ONLY BOOKIE I EVER HEARD OF GOING BROKE.Has anyone seen HAZEL DUKE'S LATLEY.That's what happen's when goverment is running thing's.What a daily doublr Hazel and Allie Sherman.A match made in heaven.
This is a non-story that will have a negligible effect on horse racing.
Steve. I understand being against Catskill fearing the same problems of NYCOTB. Who do you think should run the OTB in NY? I hope you dont think NYRA. I am a NYRA REWARDS account holder. It gives back cash each which is good,but the entire staff at BEL,AQU,SAR are clueless when it comes to horse racing and customer service, just like NYCOTB was. In fact many of the former NYCOTB managers got jobs as managers at NYRA.Old antiquates machines,broken up seating,rotton old toilets is what you get at the NYRA tracks. When the NY signal is finished, the tech crew and managers dont even change TV screens for the simulcast tracks, all you get is rolling RCN Network screens. These are just a few of my many complaints to management all falling on deaf ears. Wheres the Casino money? Its not going to improve the tracks equipment ? those antiquated machines suck! the tracks look like crap! MIKE QUEENS
The solution if you live in NY is to get a NYRA account. You can bet anywhere via cellphone, wi-fi,or phone call and get track odds.The NYRA site gives you all track video of all tracks and all tixs are cashed immediately including scratches at the gate. And there is no minimum balance or fees like TVG.
I have written this elsewhere, but the SOLUTION is Qwik Bets. Suffolk County OTB has installed Qwik Bets systems in 20 bars and restaurants across the county. It is a fantastic system: instead of some OTB parlor, you get to go to your favorite sports bar, with a regular crowd of people, and play the ponies all day if you want. Granted, if you hit a big ticket, you will need to go to an OTB window to cash out, since the bar will only have a couple hundred bucks on average. But it is so much more fun. And much less seedy. Qwik Bets would be a smashing success at sports bars in NYC, or anywhere for that matter.
James- there was a brief time when NYRA did care about their customers. A former NYRA CEO did hold monthly meetings/beatings with customers in a public forum but that ceased under Hayward. Its sad to say but NYRA management is simply punching the clock and collecting a check.
So would Catskill deduct 5%+ from the payouts? (And maybe give free mental examinations to anyone finds this acceptable.)
Can you please inform nyra board that belmont is no longer fan friendlyand aqueduct is awful lets hope this new chairman has some fresh ideas
- 1.Posted 04/12/2013 01:51PM
- 2.Posted 12/04/2013 07:01PM
- 3.Posted 12/04/2013 11:20AM
- 4.Posted 12/05/2013 04:54PM
- 5.Posted 12/05/2013 02:15PM