02/01/2013 2:42PM

Cream of last season's 3-year-old crop now standing at stud

Justin N. Lane
I’ll Have Another, winner of the 2012 Kentucky Derby, is standing at stud in Japan this year.

If a poll were taken asking participants to describe last year’s crop of 3-year-olds in one word, a popular response might be “snakebit.”

From the beginning of the Triple Crown season through the Breeders’ Cup, the division’s top males seemed to fast disappear from the racing scene, first canceling scheduled starts because of injury or illness, followed by many being shuffled off to the breeding shed for 2013.

By the end of the summer, news of another high-profile sophomore being retired to stud seemed to come on an almost weekly basis as racing fans wailed over the deteriorating state of the 3-year-old crop and the murky future of the handicap division for this year.

This attrition is best illustrated by looking at the 2012 Kentucky Derby field. Of the classic race’s 20 starters, six already have been retired to stud, including three of the top five finishers – I’ll Have Another, Bodemeister, and Creative Cause. Others in the field that have been retired to stud are Union Rags, Hansen, and Gemologist.

[DRF BREEDING: Latest news, live sale updates, Stallion Roster and more]

Of the remaining 14 horses still in training, six took hiatuses of four months or more in the latter part of 2012, and one, Sabercat, was scheduled to return at Fair Grounds on Saturday. Only five of these 14 horses have won a race since the first Saturday in May.

Aside from the Derby horses, other newly turned 4-year-olds headed to stud in 2013 include Algorithms, Empire Way, Overdriven, Thunder Moccasin, and Teeth of the Dog. Additionally, Take Charge Indy has a stall waiting for him at WinStar Farm when he is ready to call it a career.

With the news of champion 2-year-old male Shanghai Bobby already scheduled to retire at the end of the year to stand at Ashford Stud in Versailles, Ky., last year’s mass exodus from the racetrack to the breeding shed might look like a tipping point in the trend of retiring colts younger and younger.

However, Justin Zayat, racing and stallion manager of Zayat Stables, a prominent owner of numerous horses on the Triple Crown trail in recent years, said that last year’s rash of retirements could have been a fluke.

“I think most owners in the game still want to race them at four,” Zayat said. “To Honor and Serve stayed around another year, and he could have retired after three [To Honor and Serve went on to win the Grade 1 Woodward Stakes in 2012 at age 4]. I just look at it as an unlucky year.”

Zayat Stables had two of the highest-profile sophomores of last year, Grade 1 winners Bodemeister and Paynter. Both suffered career-threatening setbacks in the second half of the year, with Bodemeister retiring to WinStar Farm in Versailles, Ky., with a shoulder injury, and Paynter recovering from a highly publicized battle with colitis and laminitis to resume training in January.

While the operation has had notable horses that retired to stud early due to injury – Bodemeister and Pioneerof the Nile at WinStar and Eskendereya at Taylor Made Stallions in Nicholasville, Ky., to name a few – Zayat said the stable’s policy is to race them as long as they are sound, willing, and happy, which he said was the case with Paynter upon his recovery.

“Obviously, if a horse is running off the charts and winning numerous graded stakes, every single farm in Kentucky will be calling on that horse,” he said. “We try not to get carried away by the farms. They can always wait another year, and that’s our perspective. If they want our horse, they’ll have to wait until he’s retired.”

Rey More than 1 year ago
I'm curious to hear some commentary about the argument that many of these top three year olds are racing on steriods and that if they stay on them too long they may become infertile and of no use for breeding purposes. Could this have a bearing on early retirements?
Forego137 More than 1 year ago
Maybe you should invest in the sport and get a direct insight as to the how the sport really is so careless comments won't be made based on "Hear say" not fact. Your confusing Horse Racing with baseball. Steroids LOL
Robin Dawson More than 1 year ago
'Cream' of a very poor crop, I'm afraid. And the fact that they're all crocked and at Stud already, just confirms what a sorry state North American racing is in.
Oopsy Daisy More than 1 year ago
If you are filled with such a vile and extinguished outlook, find another sport as this one does not need your ilk.
Forego137 More than 1 year ago
Perhaps you should take the advice and seek your thrills in another sport that doesn't make you so bitter and negative and yor kind is not needed in the Sport of Kings Negative Nancy
Horse Cents More than 1 year ago
Disengenuous at best from the young Justin. If Union Rags doesn't go by Paynter in the Belmont, he would have been retired the moment he caught a cold, let along colitis. This is a feel good nothing to lose situation. If Paynter doesn't make it back, he will still have the same stud value as if he was retired last year. If he manages to win a grade 1 or a few graded stakes, his stud value could double or triple.
chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
Are you knocking both of these Colts (not Horses yet) or just one of them? Try to remember that the events of their lives are not their fault.
Guy More than 1 year ago
Justin Zayat only has a job because his father gave it to him. And that is who the DRF wanted a quote from? Laughable at best.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Or perhaps Paynter hasn't done enough on the track to get a lucrative stud deal yet.