11/16/2015 12:03PM

Bergman: Blame the system, not Sears

Michael Lisa
Brian Sears was suspended 15 days for "lack of judgment in his driving performance" by the New Jersey Racing Commission.

Apparently there is a “catch” to being a catch-driver.

Those who by definition drive horses for a living but are not directly connected to the activities that span the 72-hours or so between entry box and race date, get the brunt of the credit and blame for the results of the contest.

Brian Sears’ drive behind Bee A Magician on Friday night at the Meadowlands left a lot to be desired. Especially if one expected the former Horse of the Year to regain her winning form racing exclusively against mares after some disappointing miles against the best open competition.

That said, in my opinion, the way in which Brian Sears raced Bee A Magician on Friday night was partly due to the instructions of trainer Richard “Nifty” Norman and partly due to the bigger payday scheduled this weekend.

[DRF HARNESS LIVE: Watch all of the Meadowlands stakes action live this weekend + real-time insights from the DRF Harnes team.]

What we’d all like to point a finger at but only Brian Sears gets to pay for in a 15-day forced vacation, is that much of what goes on during the regular racing program is systematic. Systematic in a sense that the races are scheduled in a certain order and our horses just don’t have the capacity to whack out mile after mile on the front end without some residual damage being done.

The longevity of the racing season has taken its toll on many of the sport’s best performers. Maybe the owners and trainer of Bee A Magician are trying to squeeze the last drop out of the great mare before giving her a well-deserved vacation.

The number of horses that showed up for the TVG races on Friday and Saturday were dramatically low. On Saturday night, a $50,000 TVG Pacing leg was reduced to just four horses with the defection of Luck Be Withyou and Doo Wop Hanover (late scratches). Brett Miller became the Brian Sears of the night driving JK Endofanera without much aggressiveness and perhaps leaving something on the table for this Saturday’s $400,000 TVG Final.

JK Endofanera was 2-5 and could have brushed to the front at any point down the long backstretch and not likely received any resistance from pace maker Arthur Blue Chip. That is a fact that shouldn’t be overlooked by those watching these races. Sure Brett Miller was whipping and driving through the stretch so that his horse finished third, but how did that stretch exercise make up for his lack of action during the first three quarters of the race?

Realistically, we can try our best to make trainers more accountable for the performance of horses and the suggestion that the public would have been better served had they known in advance that Bee A Magician was having trouble tying up in previous races was vaguely logical.  Ultimately what we have in play are drivers, due to the fact that they earn 100 percent of their money driving for trainers, doing what’s in the best interest of themselves and their horses. Bettors come a distant third in the equation and no one should be surprised by that fact.

Brian Sears and Brett Miller earn a good living by doing right by those they drive for. Owners and trainers need to be happy when they send horses out on the track with these drivers and they need to be happy when the horses return. If either driver had overworked Bee A Magician or JK Endofanera needlessly this week, they could have lost the mount the following week. More worrisome for trainers is that they could have used up a peak performance a week earlier than one was seriously necessary.

That’s where scheduling comes in and that’s where we have to suggest that it’s not realistic to put a non-elimination race on the docket just seven days before the final event. Unlike the 2-year-old elimination races contested at the Meadowlands this past weekend, both TVG legs by nature were essentially tune-up miles for next week’s finals and a majority of the drivers performed with a modicum of interest in the outcome. Slow paces and little movement made both events discussed look more like morning qualifying miles than races bettors are supposed to wager on.

It would be nice to think that Sears’ 15-day suspension (whether he serves it or not) would send a message to other drivers, but that is unlikely to be the case. Sears gets the trophy in this one-of-a-kind effort to somehow add respectability after the fact. In reality, the judges at The Meadowlands, and pretty much every other racetrack in North America, hardly ever use the rulebook to deter drivers from perceived wrongdoing.

Sears gets vilified on Friday and Miller pretty much gets overlooked on Saturday. That’s not consistency in the judges chair and it won’t soon change the way the races play out.

The way races are conducted is what matters to bettors and their only perceived allies are the judges that rule over the events each night.

To subject trainers to weekly reports in an attempt to fill in the blanks of what goes on between races appears to be overkill. The trainers already do what is necessary to prepare their horses and they have very limited involvement (how many times have we heard leading trainers telling interviewers they don’t discuss strategy with drivers?) in what transpires on the track. To put an added burden on them to offer an “opinion” of a horse’s weekly training in my mind adds no clarity at all. Past performances spell out a horse’s condition and qualifiers assure bettors of a horse’s fitness should there be a gap between races. That serious players have access to watch past races should be more than enough to anyone interested in spending time or learning more details with credibility.

Brian Sears and Brett Miller did right by the owners and trainers this past weekend.

As Meat Loaf said, “Two out of Three Ain’t Bad.”

[DRF HARNESS EYE: Get the PPs for all the top tracks in one package with Digital Harness Eye + Analysis & Meadowlands Charts.]


Steve More than 1 year ago
Gural is a jack...he's keeping out the best trainers out of his track...now trying to keep the best drivers out of his track...Sears did nothing wrong...it was a small field because the best trainers are not allowed to race there due to his ignorance...drove the way a professional driver should drive The best trainers in Harness ...Allard..Banca..Garcia Herrera who are not allowed to race there so Burke can dominate with no competition
Joel Weiner More than 1 year ago
Classic story: there was a horse in the 1960s named Bogart Hanover. He was a top stakes horse and the owners dropped him into conditions. He was going off 1/9 from the rail. I saw his owner and followed him to the $50 window where he bet a bunch of other horses in the race but not Bogart. Well the gate swung open and Bogart dropped through the field and barely finished the race. Don't know if he ever raced again but the owner and probably the trainer made a killing while the betting public was once again played for suckers since they were the ones who bet him and didn't know that the horse was unfit to run; kinda like Bee A Magician?
Richard Gere More than 1 year ago
The harness racing ship be sinking, folks ............
Carmine Fusco More than 1 year ago
This is just another fraud being perpetrated by the commission,the meadowlands race office and most of all jeff gural. number one the judge he who has never driven a horse but is in a position to determine lack of effort,two the meadowlands who tell of the great show they put on mean while short fields which are made up of 3 or more conditions combined at draw time creating noncompetetive races and last of all the biggest fraud of all rural who is nothing more than a bully who wants only participants who will bow down to him and his nazi ways!
spanky More than 1 year ago
Have another shot of cobalt.
Jeff Mcintosh More than 1 year ago
walter More than 1 year ago
That’s where scheduling comes in and that’s where we have to suggest that it’s not realistic to put a non-elimination race on the docket just seven days before the final event. I stopped betting all elimination races years ago as they are often not much more than a training mile. Drivers, trainers an yes owners want to have a live horse in the rich final races and thus won't fully extend their animals in most elimination races. So with 12 or 13 races a night keep your money in your pocket and wait for a better situation. Actually the management would be better off not to card such races and add the purse money to the finals which are normally highly competitive. A night with say 10 competitive races is far better than a 12 or 13 race card with elimination races. Make them non betting if you need to have such races.
Joel Weiner More than 1 year ago
Elimination races are pretty much unbetable since the purses are small and all anyone wants to do is finish in the top 5 and not have to use their horse too much. There is -0- incentive to win these races. Actually on Friday there was a race where 9 out of 10 qualified for the final next week. With a chump change purse in the elimination, where is the incentive to win?
Joel Weiner More than 1 year ago
By the way, who woke up the judges?
spanky More than 1 year ago
Sears is a known crook. He knows what the rules are and he breaks them. The judges at many tracks are a joke. They DO NOT look out for the best interest of the betting public.
Vince Lentini More than 1 year ago
I didnt know leaving the gate was a rule
Jeff Mcintosh More than 1 year ago
yes but showing up ADIOS DAY whacked out of your head is`against the rules
spanky More than 1 year ago
Who said leaving the gait is a rule?
Joel Weiner More than 1 year ago
Bettors always come in last in this game and that is the tragic flaw; the folks who pay everyone's salaries don't mean squat. If any horse is not ready to win, he shouldn't be entered. A $25,000 race to Bee A Magician is meaningless. If Nifty Norman told Sears not to leave with the horse, Norman should get the 15 days. If the owner told Norman to enter but not push the horse, give the owner 15 days. This isn't the first time in harness racing that a heavy favorite has not tried and it certainly won't be the last which is why the betting public continues to stay away.
Vince Lentini More than 1 year ago
I am guessing you never owned a horse......so if a horse doesnt leave the gate a trainer should be suspended?? or only the ones you bet and lose on
Joel Weiner More than 1 year ago
I have owned horses and here the driver didn't leave the gate with an odds on horse in a crummy race because the trainer told him not to, so Sears ends up getting suspended. I didn't bet on Magician because there was no value here. You guessed wrong.
Joel Weiner More than 1 year ago
Bee A Magician doesn't need fourth money from a $25,000 purse; you want to give her a race with competition, put her in a qualifier instead of messing with the public. You embarrass harness racing by doing this.
Darren Yusko More than 1 year ago
If a horse is not ready why is the trainer sending them out to race? driver is only doing what is asked of him.in my opinion all elimination races should be non betting races and the trainer should be suspended Drivers will not push horses if they just have to be top 3 especially if they are not ready to go
Jeff Mcintosh More than 1 year ago