Updated on 05/23/2013 9:51AM

Belmont Stakes: Oxbow, Orb among 14 under consideration

Barbara D. Livingston
Oxbow (right) and Itsmyluckyday, the top two finishers in the Preakness Stakes, are under consideration for the June 8 Belmont Stakes.

The upset victory by Oxbow in the Preakness on Saturday at Pimlico extinguished the Triple Crown chances of Orb, the Kentucky Derby winner. Yet while the Belmont Stakes on June 8 at Belmont Park won’t have the drama of a Triple Crown bid, it could very well match up Oxbow and Orb, as well as prominent runners from the Derby who skipped the Preakness, and a filly.

The Belmont, at 1 1/2 miles, is the last and longest leg of the Triple Crown. As of Monday, 19 days before the Belmont, as many as 15 horses were under consideration for the race. Several are doubtful, most notably Preakness runner-up Itsmyluckyday, who most likely will make his next start at Monmouth Park.

But the Belmont field is expected to include Golden Soul and Revolutionary, who finished second and third in the Derby, then skipped the Preakness, and the filly Unlimited Budget, third last time out in the Kentucky Oaks.

D. Wayne Lukas, who trains Oxbow for the Calumet Farm of Brad Kelley, was all aglow at Churchill Downs on Monday morning when accepting congratulations throughout training hours. Lukas traveled with Oxbow by van Sunday, a 12 1/2-hour journey from Baltimore to Louisville, Ky.

Asked what he did on the long drive home, Lukas said, “Listen to my 100-plus voice mails and look at my 100-plus text messages.”

“There are a lot of very nice people out there,” he said.

The Preakness victory marked the 14th in a Triple Crown race for Lukas, breaking a record he had shared with the late, legendary “Sunny Jim” Fitzsimmons.

“I didn’t put a lot of thought into that,” Lukas said. “(Fitzsimmons) meant so much to Thoroughbred racing; that part’s a big honor. But it’s OK; I’ll put it on my résumé. It’s always a good feeling anytime you can do something nobody else has ever done.”

Lukas had last won the Preakness in 1999 and had last won a Triple Crown race in the 2000 Belmont with Commendable. Since 2000, he was winless with 31 starters in 22 Triple Crown races until Oxbow’s victory.

Lukas said Will Take Charge, seventh in the Preakness, also could run in the Belmont.

“He didn’t handle that track at all,” Lukas said. “The Belmont situation might be the best for a long-striding horse like him, with those big, sweeping turns.”

Lukas, 77, was not the oldest trainer to win the Preakness. Fitzsimmons, for instance, was 82 when he won the race with Bold Ruler in 1957. But Gary Stevens, 50, became the oldest rider to win the Preakness, supplanting Eldon Nelson, who was 45 when he won in 1972 on Bee Bee Bee.

Orb on Sunday was sent by van to Belmont Park, where trainer Shug McGaughey keeps his main string from spring until fall. McGaughey said Orb “looks to me like he came out of the race fine,” but said he wanted to get Orb settled at Belmont Park before committing to the Belmont. Orb was scheduled to go back to the track to train Wednesday.

“I want to see him bounce back, see his soundness level, his energy level,” McGaughey said Sunday. “As brilliant as we were two weeks ago, we weren’t brilliant yesterday.”

McGaughey took solace in having won the Derby two weeks earlier.

“Winning the Derby was my lifetime dream, and we won it,” he said. “I would have loved to have won (the Preakness) and taken it to another level.”

McGaughey said Orb never seemed comfortable inside horses, and that jockey Joel Rosario “never could get him outside.” But what puzzled McGaughey was how Orb steadily advanced down the backstretch, only to come up empty on the far turn.

“It looked like Orb took him to the right position, and then he didn’t have any horse,” McGaughey said. “I can’t second-guess anything that happened. It wasn’t our day. It was Oxbow’s day.”

McGaughey said that if Orb skips the Belmont, summer racing at Saratoga would likely be next.

If Oxbow and Orb face one another in the Belmont, it will mark the fourth time since 2001 that the winners of the Derby and Preakness have met in the Belmont. The last time that happened was just two years ago, with Animal Kingdom and Shackleford, both of whom were beaten by Ruler On Ice.

Six of trainer Todd Pletcher’s horses are under consideration for the Belmont, most notably Revolutionary. Palace Malice, 12th in the Derby, also is scheduled to run.

The other four Pletcher horses are all owned by Mike Repole, who on Monday said Overanalyze and the filly Unlimited Budget were certain to run, and that both Micromanage and Midnight Taboo were still in the mix.

Golden Soul will have his first breeze since the Derby “one morning this week, anywhere from Wednesday through Saturday, depending mostly on the weather,” trainer Dallas Stewart said.

Like the Lukas runners, Golden Soul is at Churchill Downs, as is Mylute, who was third in the Preakness. Mylute’s trainer, Tom Amoss, said he would wait a while before deciding whether to run in the Belmont.

Other Belmont contenders include Peter Pan Stakes winner Freedom Child and the Bob Baffert-trained Code West.

– additional reporting by David Grening and Marty McGee

Edward Tiger More than 1 year ago
ORB Bounced in Preakness Horses do that sometimes,,,,,He is a classic kind of horse and the Belmont distance will not be a proble,,,he also can run closer to the pace ,,,,most Belmonts are won closer to the lead,,,,,,as for anyone who may have any ideas that there was some sort of larceny pay off involving the jockey in the preakness,,,,,next time you slander somone make sure you know for sure what you are talking about,,,and prove it,,,ORB Will be back
Jason Hart More than 1 year ago
Edward don't be silly. Geniouses on this sight don't care about proof. They just throw out false accusations and run their mouth every time they lose their two bucks!!!
Phil Johnwell More than 1 year ago
Todd Pletcher and his gang of horses is like he'll use 3 to block for the other 2 ! If you run 4 or 5 horses in the race, then it's probable that he thinks none of them can win..His horses are just going to be getting in the way of the 1 that has a chance..
Glenn Dupuis More than 1 year ago
What happened to Governor Charlie? ? Why no news on him ? People wake up! Their missing the main horse his name is SHAM........
Phil Johnwell More than 1 year ago
Baffert ran him and he just wasn't good enough at that level..maybe he becomes a minor stakes type !
Marc E. Coakley More than 1 year ago
i don't care what anyone says..Rosario was bought off..sad too, cuz he made more than D.Wayne Lukas that day
Joe Rockhold More than 1 year ago
Yeah, after winning the World Cup and Ky Derby I'm sure Rosario is really strapped for cash. Come on now.
Jason Hart More than 1 year ago
If you really think that, then quit watching this sport and get into professional wrestling. Either way, stay off this site which is meant for people who care about horse racing and want to have legit conversations.
Joseph More than 1 year ago
To me it just looks like Pletcher is desperate for a TC win some where, so way fashion or form by considering so many from his barn. At some point the numbers will be in his favor.
Dave More than 1 year ago
So he should not run horses that belong in the race? It's not like he's throwing garbage horses into the race. Unlimited Budget is a very nice filly. I won't bet on her, but worse horses than her on paper have wound up in the Belmont winners circle!
Eddie Lazaro More than 1 year ago
Fletcher is a trainer, and a great trainer he is. He is answerable to the horse owners in his stable. Ownership has a lot of PRIDE, same with training. A lot of MONEY and HARD WORK. each and everyone around their animal wants to win. Kings and Queens, Sheiks, Dukes, etc. spend millions and millions of dollars to win the prestigious TRIPLE CROWN, even a leg of it. Saying that, You can not blame Todd if he ran all his horses at BELMONT, or any other trainer for that matter. You can say anything you want, but it is HIS PRIDE, HIS REPUTATION, HIS LIFE and LIVELIHOOD THAT IS AT STAKES. WON'T YOU DO IT IF IT WAS YOU. You are so NAIVE if you'll say NO!
Ed Greenberger More than 1 year ago
Jason Hart... twice in this thread you've said that a sloppy track favors closers. Actually, a sloppy track favors horses with speed. That is handicapping 101, my friend.
Jason Hart More than 1 year ago
No my friend....... A rock hard sealed track favors speed. A sloppy mess like they had at the derby favors closers. Horsemanship 101 my man.
Perl More than 1 year ago
That is not necessarily true. There are no absolutes when it comes to wet tracks. It depends on the track composition. I've seen plenty of days where speed ruled in the slop. I've seen closers dominate as well. B
Phil Johnwell More than 1 year ago
Absolutely right.A wet .track don't favor a closing Horse
Jason Hart More than 1 year ago
Wet track (a sealed track that is listed as wet fast) will favor speed. A deep sloppy track will favor horses from of the pace. Now is the case every single time? Of course not. But it will the majority of the time.
Dave More than 1 year ago
If Orb is okay I think he will run. I sincerely hope he gets the shot to prove the Preakness was a fluke. And I think Shug wants to show people that it was.
Jason Hart More than 1 year ago
So if Orb wins the 1 1/2 mile Belmont, it will prove that Oxbow's victory in the 1 3/16 mile Preakness was a fluke? Um......Okay.
Lindsay Lyon More than 1 year ago
I think he's referring to Orb's mediocre performance as the fluke, not Oxbow's win. Even if Orb had fired, I doubt he could have closed into that pace.
TEDK215 More than 1 year ago
pace?! 1.38 for the mile! ummmm ok!
Dave More than 1 year ago
Oxbow's win was a bit of a fluke. He pretty much galloped the first mile like a trotter. Combine that with an unfavorable post for Orb, and you basically cannot draw any conclusion about either horse. With the way Mylute was running at the end, I have to think Orb would have been making at least the same type of run if he had drawn further outside.
Billy Spathanas More than 1 year ago
How about them Boston Bruins boys and girls ....
Ray Murray More than 1 year ago
Take your hearts out of the conversation for a minute or two. Orb and or Oxbow ....are they really that good or is this just another crop of 3 year olds that has no real star or stand out performer...?
Jason Hart More than 1 year ago
Ray....... This sport wants a triple crown winner so bad, it is ridiculous. Next year, after the Derby, everyone will be putting their hopes and dreams into the Derby winner as well, claiming he/she is the next coming. Much like Orb.
Lindsay Lyon More than 1 year ago
I think that, like most years, this is an average bunch with a few nice horses at the top. I'm just hoping it doesn't end like last year, with every promising three year old out of commission by the time the Belmont results are made official.