12/27/2012 3:09PM

2012 Year In Review: Rachel, Zenyatta foals highlight breeding season

Mathea Kelley/Team Zenyatta
Zenyatta with her first foal, a Bernardini colt born March 8 at Lane’s End Farm.

Thoroughbred breeding activity continued its decline in 2012, but there were plenty of happy highlights, starting with what amounted to a pair of royal births.

Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta − Horses of the Year in 2009 and 2010 − produced their first foals in early 2012, to the delight of their fans. Rachel Alexandra’s 125-pound Curlin colt was born first, on Jan. 22 at Stonestreet Farm in Lexington, Ky., though the occasion wasn’t without some worry for her fans and the mare’s self-described “Rachel-condriac” co-owner, Barbara Banke. A week after the birth, Stonestreet revealed it had sent 6-year-old Rachel Alexandra and her newborn to the Rood and Riddle equine clinic as a precautionary measure “for pain management related to the birth.” Rachel Alexandra returned home several days later without further incident. She currently is in foal and believed to be carrying a filly, to Bernardini, who sired Zenyatta’s first foal.

Zenyatta’s foal, a 130-pound colt, was born at Lane’s End Farm in Versailles, Ky., on March 8 in possibly the most anticipated foaling since Genuine Risk produced her first live foal in 1993 after 10 years of failed attempts. When Zenyatta’s colt finally arrived, the foaling barn was filled with balloon bouquets and floral arrangements from fans and well-wishers. She currently is in foal to Tapit; her owners, Ann and Jerry Moss, generally do not fetal-sex their mares’ foals.

Zenyatta’s and Rachel Alexandra’s foals were born into a Thoroughbred world still shrinking after the 2008 global financial crisis, and a chronic commercial oversupply of Thoroughbreds hastened a collapse in North American bloodstock prices and breeding activity. Jockey Club figures released in mid-October showed continuing but shallower declines in active breeding stock. At that point, 1,861 stallions, 3.8 percent fewer stallions than a year earlier, were reported to have covered 35,391 mares, down 3 percent.

But two key areas reversed their downward trend. In New York, where Aqueduct’s slot-machine revenue was pumping up purses and breeding awards, the stallion population grew by 18 percent and mares were up by 43.1 percent. And Florida also turned the tide: The stallion ranks grew by 8.6 percent, and the mare population grew by 6.7 percent. Cape Blanco, who stands at Ashford Stud in Versailles, led all sires with 220 mares covered in 2012.

In April, Oatsee became the most prominent mare when she was named Broodmare of the Year for 2011. A 15-year-old Unbridled mare, she was the dam of three graded winners, notably Grade 1 winners Shackleford and Lady Joanne. In 2012, Oatsee’s credentials improved further when Stephanoatsee became her fifth stakes winner, Afleeting Lady won her first graded stakes, and Shackleford, already the 2011 Preakness winner, won the Grade 1 Metropolitan and Clark Handicaps before retiring to Darby Dan Farm in Lexington.

Sire leaders

The race for 2012’s general sire title is about as close as it can get. Nearing the end of December, a mere $28,000 separated leader Speightstown from his nearest rival, Giant’s Causeway, who was just $52,000 ahead of Empire Maker in third. The freshman sire rankings also were tight, with Henrythenavigator holding a narrow lead of $54,000 over Spring At Last, who fielded just 71 juveniles, as compared to Henrythenavigator’s 112.

The margins were more decisive in the other categories. Harlan’s Holiday, sire of Breeders’ Cup Juvenile winner Shanghai Bobby, was the top juvenile sire; Storm Cat, the broodmare sire of Kentucky Derby and Preakness runner-up Bodemeister, led the broodmare sire list; and Dynaformer, sire of course-record-setter and three-time Grade 1 winner Point of Entry, was the year’s leading turf sire.

The famously irascible and much-loved Dynaformer died in April at Three Chimneys Farm, at age 27, but by year’s end his sons were poised to open a new era at Calumet Farm under billionaire Brad M. Kelley. In May, the late Henryk de Kwiatkowski’s heirs ended weeks of excited speculation when they announced they had sold the historic “crown jewel of the Bluegrass” to a group headed by Kelley, the publicity-shy owner of Bluegrass Hall who reportedly would lease the farm from the partners. The price was $35.9 million. At 55, Kelley is one of the nation’s largest landowners, with an estimated 1.7 million acres in Texas, Florida, and New Mexico. He is also a breeder and owner whose horses include 2012 graded winner Optimizer.

Four months before selling Calumet, the de Kwiatkowski Trust had announced it would revive Calumet’s long-dormant stallion barn and stand Cactus Ridge and Ice Box, the first stallions to stand there in more than a decade. After the sale, those two horses relocated, and Kelley brought in the Dynaformer stallions Americain and Lentenor, the latter a full brother to 2006 Kentucky Derby winner Barbaro, and the Yes It’s True horse Aikenite to launch Calumet’s new era.

Other notable farms also changed hands in 2012. Tom Simon put his multi-state Vinery operation on the market, selling its Florida training center to Barbara Banke’s Stonestreet Farms in December. Simon and partners will retain the farm’s Australian division. In New York, Questroyal and Gus Schoenborn Jr. bought Sez Who North, once the state’s leading breeder. And Meadow Farm, Secretariat’s birthplace that became part of the Virginia State Fair, brought $5.35 million at a foreclosure auction, selling to Universal Fairs.

For stallion owners, 2012 looked much like 2011, with many opting to hold the line or trim stud fees in an effort to draw mares from a shrinking – and highly selective – pool. Book sizes and fees for the most successful and popular stallions remained high, but competition for middle-market stallions continued to be fierce. This situation and still-stringent credit requirements continued to dampen the stallion-prospect market for all but the choicest colts who combined superior pedigrees and race records. Owner Paul Reddam, who sold 2012 Derby and Preakness winner I’ll Have Another to Japanese interests for $10 million, was surprised to receive just two offers for the colt from American farms that had valued him at between $3 million and $5 million.


The last crop of yearlings by A.P. Indy, the 1994 Horse of the Year, went to auction in 2012, and he was among the horses pensioned from stallion duty this year. But the most shocking stallion loss came Dec. 8, when Pulpit, Claiborne Farm’s homebred flagbearer and one of A.P. Indy’s most successful stallion sons, died in his paddock at the age of 18.

Richland Hills Farm − whose owner, Nathan Fox, launched Dynaformer’s stud career − endured hard losses when its young stallions Purim and Sightseeing died after colicking. Purim, 10, was a son of Dynaformer. Sightseeing, 8, was by Pulpit, and he died the same week as his sire. Coolmore also lost a pair of valuable young sires: Montjeu, 16, died in March after developing septicemia, and Grand Slam, 17, died of heart failure the following month.

Other notable stallions who died in 2012 include Royal Academy, Theatrical, Refuse to Bend, Fortunate Prospect, Skip Trial, Aptitude, Key Contender, Lit de Justice, Kitalpha, and Deputed Testamony.

Breeding also lost such prominent mares as champion Hollywood Wildcat, dam of War Chant; 6-year-old Maram, the 2008 Breeders’ Cup Juvenile Fillies Turf winner who died in September of an unidentified acute illness; 11-year-old Grade 1 winner and producer Madcap Escapade, after colicking; French and German champion Borgia, runner-up in the 1997 Breeders’ Cup Turf; Grade 1 winner Trumpet’s Blare; Irish champion Ministrella; and Irish Oaks winner Colorspin, dam of Opera house, among others.

The Thoroughbred breeding community also lost many renowned breeders, including Moyglare Stud owner Walter Haefner and longtime Kentucky-based breeders Louise Humphrey, Bayne Welker Sr., and Indian Creek Farm president David C. Parrish Jr. Harold McCormick, co-owner of Rachel Alexandra, died in March, a few months after Rachel delivered her first foal, and another owner, Don Little, died after a show-jumping accident. Joe Allbritton, whose Lazy Lane Farm in Virginia campaigned 1991 champion 3-year-old Hansel, died in December. Other notables deaths in 2012 were New York farm owners James Edwards and Gus Schoenborn Sr., Maryland breeder Sondra Bender, California breeder Larry Mabee, and Kentucky farm owners Frank Justice and Eamon Cleary.

Andres Javier Maverino More than 1 year ago
bernardini perdio con invasor 2006??? esta es la yegua qu dicen..... mejor caballo de la historia...como vi en un informe publicado sin respetar la historia de secretariat
Susan Huart More than 1 year ago
Insightful article. Too bad so much emphasis is placed on a few stars of TR and not spread around to help those many discarded racing athletes that deserve to procreate as well. I too am still fascinated by the brilliant Zenyatta, RachelAlexandra, Secretariat and so many more. But perhaps if the industry did more to help the racehorse deemed unworthy of breeding as a second career, there wouldn't be the horrific consequences of their fate.
Diane Lebowitz More than 1 year ago
FYI - A.P Indy was Horse of the Year in 1992, not 1994. Holy Bull was Horse of the Year in 1994.
Kim More than 1 year ago
So sad to see all those lost in 2012, listed in the above article. Too bad those that weren't as well-known and lost in 2012, weren't listed as well. Echoing Skip Ean and comedyflyer, too many of these wonderful Thoroughbreds are sent to auction and bought by "kill buyers" for slaughter. With some of the money that I saw mentioned in this article and knowing what other money was not mentioned, funding needs to be setup for Thoroughbreds that don't want to be racehorses. I am a racing fan, don't get me wrong, but the black-eye the sport has from their horses falling through the cracks and ending up with shady trainers/owners, then as someone's dinner, has got to stop. These horses may not be racers but they can go on to second careers as hunters, jumpers or someone's trail horse. Please stop and take a look around for some of these success stories. Most won't need funding from breeders and/or owners if they are given the opportunity for a second chance.
Horse Cents More than 1 year ago
As an owner/breeder I used to buy horses from the track that were potentially headed to slaughter and would have them trained for hunter/jumpers, then resell them to that market where a 25 year career is not unusual. The problem is training is not cheap, takes a long time, and is always a money loser and can't do it forever without other funding.
Dave Schuler More than 1 year ago
I Hope Little Zenatta,s @ Havre de Graces,little one haVE A SAFE LIFE @MEET sOMEDAY oN tRACK-LOLK-ds
Bustedbox2 More than 1 year ago
So, after The New York Times' hatchet job on I'll Have Another and his connections nobody wants him, and he's been sold to Japan. See "The Old Grey Lady Dons a Flashy Saffron Gown," http://www.curmudgeonscorner.net/horseracing.html . All I can say is remember Sunday Silence, the world's leading sire by his progeny's earnings. None of the American breeders wanted him either.
Bustedbox2 More than 1 year ago
Dynaformer, Pulpit, Hollywood Wildcat, Grand Slam gone, A.P. Indy pensioned off -- I don't know how I'll handicap anymore. I'll particularly miss Dynaformer's progency on the grass. I was once betting a maiden special weight on the turf at Saratoga when I noticed I'd overlooked a Dynaformer. "Oh,no, I missed a Dynaformer," I told my wife. She sprinted to the window and bet him just before they left the gate. He won.
Skip Ean More than 1 year ago
Despite the statements in the above article that say birth rates are down, we are still seeing outrageous statements like Capo Blanco covering 220 mares this past year. And he is just one stallion in demand--there are so many more. Most wind up at the bottom of the spiral in racing and are then sold to kill buyers and become burgers for Europe and Japan. Enough! I know horses are a business, but perhaps if all these greedy breeders went to a horse slaughterhouse, particularly in Mexico, they would see, hear, smell and experience horrific torture and death. They need to see that. They need to stop this lust for money in the breeding shed. I'm sure others can say this more eloquently, but I'm saying STOP and do you have the courage to go and watch unwanted horses being slaughtered for a few hours to see what the end result of your greed becomes.
PeterG More than 1 year ago
Do you eat meat? Slaughtering a horse is no different than slaughtering a pig, a cow, a deer, chicken, turkey whatever. It's gruesome to see but everybody still eats the meat. If you don't want them slaughtered, why don't you go down there and get them and pay to take care of them the rest of their lives. It's the food chain. It's part of life. And a higher power than you created it. Ever watch a bear or lion tear another animal apart? That's gruesome too but the bear and lion still enjoy the meat. I've got no problem with horses being slaughtered. And obviously Japan and Europe don't either.
Maynard More than 1 year ago
Pigs, cows, deer, chickens,turkeys, goats and sheep have not had a coddled life. We generally do not know them by name. To force horses that have been treated like royalty to suffer the indignities of being pushed form place to place with no concern for their comfort or mental status is cruel and unusual punishment. We don't do it to dogs openly for the same reason. If breeding were for the highest quality and not just a crap shoot, we would not have so many unwanted, unusable animals. Stop overbreeding stock that have shown any soundness and temperament issues. Breed the best to the best, hope for the best and find good homes for the rest.
richard montgomery More than 1 year ago
Go jump into a lions den peter.
Pom De Terre More than 1 year ago
I couldn't agree more. 220 covers in a season is about 100 too many. Sounds like the connections are turning Capo Blanco into another Alydar, and we all know how that story turned out.
chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
Seems that stuff would be alittle watered down don't it Tater? These foal factories are outa control.
Kimberly Shugars More than 1 year ago
Cape Blanco is no Alydar and the Coolmore/Ashford folks are no JT Lundy's. The insinuation that Cape Blanco will end up being murdered because he is being overbred is ridiculous. Also, Cape Blanco DID stand both Northern and Southern Hemisphere seasons. He shuttles to New Zealand.
Kimberly Shugars More than 1 year ago
My first question would be, did Cape Blanco stand both the Northern and Southern Hemisphere seasons ? If so, 220 is not an unusually high number. Hard Spun stood both seasons last year and covered more than 220 mares. He covered 142 in the US alone. But, in Hard Spun's case, He is the 2012 second crop sire leader and his fillies are showing exceptional promise (Questing, Hard not to Like). I always thought he would eventually be considered Danzigs best sire son. I know thats a tall order considering Danehill and War Front's successes but he is a young stallion with a very bright future who will be getting better and better mares now that his offspring are proving successful on the track. We have yet to see what Cape Blanco will bring us.
chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
Kimberly, even with stress on the Stallion aside, just to find that many Mares with any kind of line would be a task. They must leave the barn door open.
Kimberly Shugars More than 1 year ago
Seriously Chad, do you really think that they are going to close the breeding shed door when breeders are willing to shell out enormous stud fee's ? No one is saying these mares possess more than average lineage. All im saying, is when a stallion is servicing both hemispheres 220 is not an unusually large number of mares. it's 110 each, however i expect he bred more mares in the US than he did in New Zealand. The US breeding season lasts about 120-140 days, taking that into consideration thats less then one mare per day. Alydar was breeding up to 4 times a day at the end of his life. That would be what I called stress because from all acounts, stallions really like their jobs.
Judy Maass Gadwood More than 1 year ago
I will follow Queen Zenyatta - and her offspring - to the end of the earth :-)
chad mc rory More than 1 year ago
Two hundred-twenty mares... Six times more than the number of Secretariat shares sold.