12/14/2010 4:21PM



In a few weeks time, Zenyatta will join the mighty Azeri as the only three-time consecutive Eclipse Award winners in the "Older Female" category.

Not counting Parlo (1954 Champion Handicap Mare, Alternate Selection by TRA in 1955), Old Hat (Alternate Selection by TRA in 1965, Champion Handicap Mare in 1966), and Gamely (1968 Champion Handicap Mare, Alternate Selection by TRA in 1969), the only other "undisputed" consecutive older distaff champions are Shuvee (1970-71), Bayakoa (1989-90), and Paseana (1992-93). 

So, in the spirit of the Eclipse Awards, let's take a trip back in time to 1971 and relive the words of the legendary turf writer Charles Hatton as he recaps Shuvee's second championship season in his "Profiles of Best Horses" column in the 1972 American Racing Manual:

"Shuvee was among the stoutest racemares ever seen on the American turf in this century, and some of her achievements have a challenging singularity.  Uniquely, she is the richest thoroughbred of her sex in history, having amassed $890,445 in four spot-resistant campaigns during which she was 16 times first, 10 times second and six times third in 44 starts.  Again, none of her sex had won the two-mile, weight-for-age Jockey Club Gold Cup, this country's premier test of stamina, until she brought it off at four in 1970. 
Authenticating this feat, she "blazed her name on a shining hour" concluding her career with a second Cup triumph in smashing style on October 30, 1971.  When it was seen Shuvee had her field in trouble keeping in touch swinging for home, the crowd rose to its feet and cheered her home in a Niagara of sound that made trainer Mike Freeman glad he had packed her ears with cotton.  The fans were always devoted to her, many had backed her, and all were delighted with the poetic result of her finale.
In the course of her last campaign, the Whitney Stones' golden chestnut Amazon won the Top Flight and Diana as well, both also for the second time.  Earlier on, when she was three, the aristocratic daughter of Nashua and Levee with the non-stop pedigree had carried off the NYRA's Triple Crown for Fillies.
The most blase sophisticate among racing men of taste must concede Shuvee was "one of the ones," memorable enough to be categorized with Busher, Twilight Tear and Gallorette of the tote era.  Actually, the mere mention of her name takes us back 50 years to the only Regret and the four-mile champion, Sotemia."

"This not fulsome praise, more subjective than objective, but in the interest of giving credit where it is due.  It is expressed in behalf of all who admire an exceptional thoroughbred, we are sure.  All racegoers must be profoundly grateful for the absolutely riveting performances she afforded, and we cheerfully acknowledge the indebtedness.
Shuvee now has congratulated herself through warranting notice in these studies in a third edition of the American Racing Manual.  Few of her species have the character, toughness of fibre and good fortune to command interest in a profile one season.  Her reappearance is a testimonial to her class and in turn speaks eloquently for her sound breeding and thoughtful handling. 
'Personality' is perhaps malapropos applied to any equine.  The purists term this temperament.  And yet veteran racing men are aware the species are almost unalike as people in their natures.  There are the gentlemen and ladies among them, while others are full of low cunning and just plain common, given to all manner of evil tricks.  Some are mettlesome and gay, others phlegmatic and even morose.  They may be overbred and complicated, or underbred and degenerate.
In very many instances, the thoroughbred's behavior patterns reflect the patience or want of it on the part of their familiars.  A handler may spoil his charge by bullying, whipping and snatching him about, or again by indulging one who himself wants to be a bit of a tyrant. 
Obviously, a plucky competitor has spirit.  But there is no inflexible corollary between bad temper and racing capacity, though a neurotic and spooky animal or a sulker poses problems which often adversely influence his form.
If we may cite a few of the more bizarre specimens without being accused of treachery and character assassination, Dr. Fager occurs to us as a horse who could easily have been made a difficult customer.  Impetuous, imperious, conceited and hard-mouthed, he was also prodigiously stong.  Willie Shoemaker with his light hands found him unmanageable.  Mad Hatter was an errant rogue and sulker, while Display was berserk at the barrier, if not quite mad.  Conversely, there was Eight Thirty, who was galloped by a 90-pound man of 60.  And old Peter Pan, who was ridden to town for the mail as a stud horse, and who was trustworthy as any babysitter.
Remember that many otherwise quite civil animals will become a bit irritable when tightened for a race.
It was never a question when progeny of Bull Lea were ready to run, for they became so tense they would reach over the bar of the stall to snap at bypassers.  Always, they told Ben Jones when they wanted racing, as if he hadn't got the message and needed prompting."

"There is a quaint tradition of misanthropy among good racemares.  It is a tradition.  Artful did nothing to controvert when she broke her Mexican groom's arm, or when she was shipped to England to be bred to a celebrated stallion and preserved her chastity tearing up the hobbles and clearing the breeding shed. 
At length, this brings us to Shuvee.  She is a daring and absolutely unflappable mare in the heat of conflict, almost literally tearing down the fence to get to Personality and bring him to terms in the 1970 Woodward.  Her every fibre exudes self confidence and poise.  But only when she is drawn for a race does she become the least bit snappish.
Actually, Shuvee was a great favorite with trainer Mike Freeman and his aides throughout her career.  She showed only one or two little idiosyncrasies.  She found the stretch run a wall of noise that could be distracting.  She ran equipped with no prohibitive gear, but her ears were stuffed with cotton.
Many masculine type mares show no marked deviation from their best form when they are horsing, but Shuvee is not among them.  Not to be indelicate, but she comes in season regularly in warm weather.  As her form lapsed at such times, Freeman adopted a policy of affording her summer vacations.
Also, she was given to switching her tail in a drive, like a horse ready to sulk or beat a retreat.  But she never turned it up, really.  She had far too much competitive instinct for that.  'Flagging' can be terribly disconcerting if one has a ticket on the horse, but it meant nothing ominous in the instance of Shuvee.  Nor, one might add, in the case of But Why Not, who won an Arlington Classic in rather flamboyant style.
Shuvee is at once aware and composed, thus one does not wonder the stable entourage was so fond of her and found handling her so much good fun.  She trained alone, and raced with no inhibitive equipment.  Also she was a splendid doer, and retired perfectly sound, while fit enough to win a Jockey Club Gold Cup. 
It is tempting to keep one such in training, but her people resisted, and in any case she'd done quite enough.  We should think it would have been impossible for her to improve on her striking Gold Cup success as an encore.
The will to win was obsessive, and rarely did she run a sorry race.  As previously noted in these "petite histoires," the only filly or mare of Shuvee's time who appeared to be more capable was the King Ranch's Gallant Bloom.  A superb racing tool, Gallant Bloom repeatedly debited our heroine with defeat. But she was far less robust, less a proven stayer, and unsoundness rudely terminated her brilliant career.
They were antitypes.  A fastidious doer with a suspicious ankle, Gallant Bloom required the most solicitous handling, but she could run with telling effect when pointed for a specific race.  Shuvee was perhaps a bit less speedy and clever, but a far more durable campaigner and seemingly indefatigable.  Gallant Bloom was wirehung, graceful as a ballet dancer, and with catlike agility.  This was to her advantage when opposing Shuvee, enabling her to get the jump on the Stone filly.  
Match them every week end, and we dare say Shuvee would have won the most races, and we wonder if the delicate Gallant Bloom could have come to taw a third time.  This may seem cavalier, but it states the case fairly.
Shuvee is unexceptionable on the score of individuality and constitution, and her physique and breeding are equally recherche.  She is a massive golden chestnut.  To particularize, Dr. M. A. Gilman measured her at 16.1 hands, while she girthed a phenomenal 76 inches, measured 42 inches from hip to hock and boasted 8 1/4 inches of bone below the knee. 
She is a big mare without being at all vulgar or coarse in any particular."

"Her neck is arched and breedy, so that she is readily mistaken for an entire horse from a distance, and she has a head of marvelous refinement, reflecting her high breeding.  The jowls are deep and flat, the forehead prominent, the muzzle delicately modeled, the throatlatch clean and arching.  A fairly prominent star is her only marking.
She forks up narrowly enough for a mare of such magnificent middle, has a deep, well-placed scapula, good length from elbow to knee, flat bone, fair pasterns and feet, and smooth coupling.  There is no hint of weakness in the flank.  On the contrary we should say.  She emerged each spring looking like a mare heavy in foal and required considerable legging up. 
Shuvee has formidable muscular investiture, of the long-staying sort, about the quarters, implementing the built-in propulsive thrust of her length from hip to hock. 
Her action is head down, low and determined.  She is the antithesis of the highflier.  She has less verve than her ancient rival Gallant Bloom, but goes with relentless, pendulistic strokes and has won frequently by pulling out that little bit of extra right on the post.  As you might imagine, Shuvee prefers the traction afforded by glib, dry surfaces.  She went swimmingly and lost her action on shifty surfaces at Delaware and Liberty Bell the year before last.  But she negotiates mud with astonishing facility, as also did her dam. 
Shuvee's genealogy is a fascinating exercise in breeding the best to the best, and argues for class in the dam, if any further argument was necessary.  As most know, her sire Nashua was a millionaire race horse of the Nearco tribe through Nasrullah.  He won the Hopeful, Futurity, Preakness (in record time), a match against Swaps, the Gold Cup and other distinguished events.  Mr. Fitz reckoned him 'a natural stayer.'
Nashua had speed on demand, but disliked fielding clods racing inside, while his illustrious daughter would run through a wall.  Levee was an Oaks champion, and is a champion producer.
Levee is a half-sister to Delta, Bayou and Banta and her own foals include a sister to Shuvee in Nalee, who was in the best class, not to mention the useful Royal Gunner and the clever turf course performer A T's Olie.
This family was bred up from humble origins through shrewdly selective breeding.  It has improved from generation to generation, Shuvee marking its apogee.
Hal Price Headley used to say, accurately, that 'a good mare is better than a life annuity.'  And he would add, 'In the old days, families fortunate enough to have one of these 'blue hens' would as soon part with one of their daughters as one of the mare's fillies.  In fact, the only way one could get one of these fillies was to marry into the breeders' family.'  As a postscript, he gave fillies from Alcibiades' family to various of the Headley family as wedding presents."

"Levee's production record challenges comparison.  As we recall, Jersey Lightning had five foals, all of whom won, four of them stakes winners including Regret and Thunderer, who won the Derby and Futurity the same year.
Fairy Gold had 11 foals, nine winners and five stakes winners, among them Fair Play, Friar Rock and Flittergold.  Frillery had 11 foals, seven winners, four of them stakes winners, including Bunting.  Miss Kearney produced 12 foals, 10 winners and included Zev among her four stakes winners.  Marguerite had nine foals, five of whom won, four of them in stakes company, including Gallant Fox.  La Troienne dropped six winners in six foals, four of them stakes winners, among them Black Helen and Bimelech.  Rose Leaves produced nine foals, six winners and five stakes winners including Bull Lea.  Margaret Lawrence had nine winners from as many foals, five of them stakes winners, including Lawrin.  And Filante had 16 foals, nine winners, seven of these, including Fenelon, in stakes races.  But we digress.  Since the grand idea is to improve the breed, our compliments to A. B. Hancock, who developed Shuvee's matriarchy, and to the Whitney Stones, who bred the dual Jockey Club Gold Cup winner."

Shuvee's lifetime past performances are listed at the bottom of this blog posting. 

Shuvee's page at the National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame website can be found at:


Here's a partial video clip of Shuvee winning the 1970 Jockey Club Gold Cup.



Congrats to Al Perl for finishing first in last week's HandiGambling exercise.  For this week's race, he chooses the eighth at Fairgrounds on Thursday afternoon. 


Remember that you have a mythical $100 with which to wager on the race, and the entrant with the highest money total will receive a "Monthly Enhanced 60-Card Past Performance Plan." Anyone going over the $100 limit will be disqualified. Please post your plays and analysis to the blog. In the event of a tie, the earliest post gets first preference. One entry per person please. I reserve the right to approve or deny any entries.

I know that there is a time issue for some of you, but let's remember why we began the HandiGambling races in the first place. The goal was to share ideas on why we like these horses, and why we're betting them the way we are. I'm not asking for a novel, but if you could spare a sentence or two outlining your handicapping angles, and thought processes about wagering, it would be appreciated.

Shuvee.pdf71.92 KB
HG 214.pdf168.52 KB
Patrick S More than 1 year ago
HG214: Trying to hit the trifecta keying on the 4 as a long shot play in the 2 and 3 hole, with the 7,8,10 on top. Hopefully another price hits with the 4. $3 TRI (7,8,10/4/1,2,5,7,8,9,10) $2 TRI (7,8,10/1,2,5,7,8,9,10/4) $5 TRI (7/10,8/4) GL All.
william More than 1 year ago
love grey horses on soft turf will put the 100 to win on 9
Dick W More than 1 year ago
HG214 Looks like no scratches and turf course was listed as good this morning. I posted my analysis yesterday so will now post my bet. I focused on 5 horses: #7 - Brentwood Bullet, #10 - Joinem, #2 - Dr. Alex, #8 - Tight Grip and #1 - Gangbuster. I will box those 5 in a $1 tri box and use the top 3 in exacta boxes as follows: $1 tri box 1,2,7,8,10 ($60) $10 ex box 7,2 ($20) $10 ex box 7,10 ($20) Good luck to all !!! Dick W
SteveC More than 1 year ago
HG214 #1 Gangbusters - Looks like he might want longer, but should be competitive in this one. Like that he was rolling late in his last and should be improving 2nd off the short layoff #7 Brentwood Bullet - Will be much closer to the front in this one where he likes it. Only question what happens if he gets into it with #8 Tight Grip. #8 Tight Grip - Could be stuck behind #7. Seems to want the lead more than pressing. I'll take a chance and assume he's not getting the lead and will lose interest. #10 Joinem - On paper, much the best out of these. Only worry would be the outside post and whether he'll be hung out to dry. Bet: $52 W #10 $20 Ex 10 - 7 $10 Ex 7 - 10 $3 Ex box 1-7-10
Alan More than 1 year ago
Greetings from snowy Baltimore!! Still arguing about Zenyatta vs Blame? And who can forget Goldikova? Meanwhile, yet another filly has proved her greatness against the boys in Grp1 races - 3yo Snow Fairy: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UqYgbVRr26I Snow Fairy BTW was a "...1,800 Euros buy-back purchase as a yearling..." What a bargain! http://www.thoroughbrednews.com.au/international/default.aspx?id=50395 I'm off to Laurel tomorrow with Katieattherail and hubby Ed. In LRL7 tomorrow, there is a 725k FTS named Listen Here. She is by Bernardini out of unraced Listen Now, the dam of stakes winners Listen Here and Indy Bird. The 2nd dam Listen Well produced multi-stakes winners Listening and Beautiful Noise. It is quite an interesting little 2yo filly msw for a frigid Friday LRL card, including a mix of other fairly well bred FTSs as well as 2ndTS and 3rdTS, but if Listen Now stays near her ML of 6/1 I'll play her. While I'm at it, I'll try a little HandiGambling: HG at the BIG EASY SELECTIONS: I'm a believer in using prior FG turf success as a factor when handicapping these type of races, so I'm most interested in a few here: #3 Ice Climber -> 2-1-0-0 on FG turf, including recent win in n1x company at same distance 19 days ago. Retains Theriot as well. #4 Mountain Justice -> 3-2-1-0 on the FG turf, 4-0-0-0 otherwise. Graham was aboard for both of those FG wins. #7 Brentwood Bullet -> 4-2-1-1 on FG turf, won with Albarado earlier this year, won off layoff here last year. #2 Dr Alex and #1 Gangbuster finished 1st and 3rd last month in same company/distance. Both have won only once in 5 tries on the FG lawn. WAGER: Will KEY #3, #4 and #7 on top and include #1 and #2 as well in exotic wagers. $5EX #3,4,7/1,2,3,4,7 = $60 $1TRI #3,4,7/1,2,3,4,7/1,2,3,4,7 = $36 $0.10SUPER #3,4,7/3,4,7/1,2,3,4,7/1,2,3,4,7 = $3.60 $0.10SUPER #7/3,4/3,4/1,2 = $0.40 $100 TOTAL Good luck today!
Dick W More than 1 year ago
Laura Just so there is no confusion, Sunday is the 19th not the 18th. Also, my thoughts are with you and your parents in the coming days. Dick W
blackstone More than 1 year ago
Kyri The Jockey club web site does list the participating tracks, but does not show, at least anywhere I could find, the data by track. I have sent them an email asking if I can have that data-for my own self interest I also asked for at least the California Tracks so that they could be compared to the norm. We'll see what they say, if anything.
Annie More than 1 year ago
Kyri, I agree that is a very important component in trying to truly determine if there is much difference between the surfaces as far as mortality rate. The cheaper horses are going to break down more often just because so many more of them have soundness issues. Even running on grass, which you would think would be their natural surface, does not protect them from injury and death. It's a very sad fact of racing and I wish there was an answer. Annie
Van Savant More than 1 year ago
HandiGambling 214 I settled on three horses that I believe stand the best chance to finish first in this race, and then a few others to pick up the pieces. DR. ALEX (#2), ICE CLIMBER (#3), and JOINEM (#10) are those three. All three have the class and closing style to threaten here. BRAD’S MY HERO (#5) may be a cut below, but can finish here. TIGHT GRIP (#8) has the speed to lead and may hang on for a piece. My play; $2 Superfecta – 10w/2,3w/2,3,5,8w/2,3,5,8 ($24) $3 Superfecta – 2w/3,10w/3,5,8,10w/3,5,8,10 ($36) $3 Superfecta – 3w/2,10w/2,5,8,10w/2,5,8,10) ($36) $4 to Win on the 2 ($4) That’s the hondo. Thanks Dan.
Turnbackthealarm More than 1 year ago
Kyri, Good observation on the class differences between the tracks. Those differences could very easily skew the results. Having said that, what do you think the odds are that no one thought of it and allowed for it? After all, we still haven't had a report on the Life at Ten debacle and it's been six weeks! I guarentee I could have had it done in six days......... Midwest Ed, I am with you on the med violations. They should be noted. SR Vegas, Are you planning on jamming the ballot box for Z? Off topic: Whacky, I was at the Bears-New England game. Tom Brady made a mockery of the second ranked defense in the NFL. Having said that, given the sight lines and frozen-ness of the field, the receivers were at a marked advantage over the defensive backs since they KNEW where they were going! haha The winds were so bad that if the windows on the box were opened even a crack, snow was blowing in. The stadium itself functioned like a huge toilet bowl with winds swirling all around the bowl. Some fans were letting plastic bags loose just to watch their weird trip around the staium. Miserable does not even begin to describe how bad the conditions were.
JIMPEREGOY More than 1 year ago
HG 214 There are no obvious tosses for low % connections. Not sure of par, but suspect that winner will have to Beyer in the 85 to 90 range. Will toss the 3, 5 and 6. Tope Beyer for that group is 80. This leaves a field of 7 to evaluate for win honors. 1-Gangbuster has top Beyer (94) but earned in May) 2-DR. Alex has the late turn of foot that you like in a turfer, but deep closer could have traffic issues. 4-Mountain Justice has an 85 Beyer, but this figure is 13 months old. Too slow recently. 7-Brentwood Bullet has 2nd best Beyer (90), but he achieved this in March. Off since August, but gets a very positive rider change to Alvarado. 8-Tight Grip fits from Beyer standpoint and gets positive rider change to Napravnik. Away since August, but his 11/19 in the exacta is encouraging. 9-Precious Colony is ditto about without the rider change, but runs at mongrel tracks. 10-Joinem is not the most logical morning line favorite I have seen, but he is a few feet from being undefeated on turf. I am going to look for Anna to steal this on the lead or stalking and will key the 8 for this HG renewal. $50 to win #8 $20 Exactas 8 over 7 + 10 = $40 $10 Exacta 8 over 1
jesse dunn More than 1 year ago
HG 214 40$ex 10/4 15$ex 10/1-9 10$ex 4/10 5$tri 10/7-8/4 1$tri 10/1-4-9/1-4-9 2$ex 4/1-9 #4 is very interesting with huge local race and upside potential as lightly raced. #10 is very much the horse to beat and is hard to leave out of the exacta. #1 and #9 have back races that fit here and should be overlay's. good luck