03/30/2010 2:39PM

Fractionally speaking, four more preps

Email

FLORIDA DERBY

First off, dismiss the notion that Ice Box and Pleasant Prince are one-off flukes that capitalized on a suicidal pace in the Florida Derby. This wasn't Giacomo in the 2005 Kentucky Derby. The Florida Derby pace was contentious and certainly honest, but nothing scintillating. After all, if the pace was that fast, would Pulsion have been able to go head-and-head for the lead? The Florida Derby pace figures (on the Moss Pace Figure scale) of 76-86-90-92-92F were right in line with the six-year average for the race of 77-85-91-93-93F, compiled since Gulfstream's oval was screwed up reconfigured in 2005. Rule and Pulsion set a pace quite a bit slower than Big Brown zipped through two years ago, but quicker than the pace of Casey's On Call that Quality Road tracked last year.

Rule had a similar paceline in the Sam Davis of 78-84-89-92F, a little faster at the first quarter and a length or two slower at the half and three-quarters. He deserves kudos for running eye-to-eye with Pulsion and staying relaxed enough to pretty much run his usual race, but he's probably looking at the same type of trip in the Kentucky Derby, given the quantity of early speed we're seeing this season. Ice Box seems to have a slight edge over Pleasant Prince, but to me, the Florida Derby pace figures indicate these two colts are exactly what they seem: improving 3-year-olds with competitive numbers and a running style that often works well the first Saturday in May.

LOUISIANA DERBY

In this rescheduled and lengthened mile-and-an-eighth running, predictions that Discreetly Mine would face more pace pressure than he did in the Lecomte held true. But the Louisiana Derby pace wasn't even as quick as what we saw at Gulfstream, which explains why stretching-out A Little Warm and Discreetly Mine were still hanging so grittily in the closing stages. A Little Warm showed the way before yielding late to Mission Impazible in 78-79-88-89-90F - a touch quicker in the opening stages than the Florida Derby as the 13-horse field tried to get position around the first turn, but then relaxing noticeably in the middle stages. In the Lecomte, Discreetly Mine had been ignored on the lead in 67-75-84-90F, and wasn't about to get that kind of soft trip again. He ran decently nonetheless, but didn't finish as if a sternly-paced mile-and-a-quarter would be his cup of tea.

It's much easier to say now, but Mission Impazible's Southwest Stakes effort was better than it looked on paper. Breaking from the far outside post going a mile, he was hustled to the first turn by Eibar Coa but still wound up three-wide, then was put into a hard drive three furlongs out only to get caught four-wide around the second turn. When Dublin rushed past him nearing the stretch, it briefly appeared Mission Impazible was in a retreating mode, but he actually finished about as well as the horses in front of him. By comparison, he got a perfect ground-saving trip in the Louisiana Derby, which creates the impression he's not quite as good as he looked at Fair Grounds but better than he finished at Oaklawn.

Kent Desormeaux rode Drosselmeyer the only way he could have, brilliantly maneuvering him to the inside from the No. 13 post position and establishing rail position around both turns. Unfortunately, that also led to the traffic problems Drosselmeyer faced through the lane. As a grind-it-out type of runner with little quick acceleration, Drosselmeyer couldn't get through the inside hole aggressively enough when it finally did open up, and his third-place finish probably won't be good enough to land him a spot in the Kentucky Derby field.

LANE'S END STAKES

Since Turfway Park switched to Polytrack prior to the fall 2005 meeting, the Lanes End pacefigs have averaged 67-69-80-88-91F -- including Hard Spun's '07 victory that was run in almost a dirt-like fashion. This year, Dean's Kitten raced within a couple lengths of the pace in 63-63-78-88-90F.

What does that mean? Good question. Wish I had a good answer.

Dean's Kitten is obviously a decent horse, but it is hard to take him seriously for the Kentucky Derby since his only previous dirt effort -- a washed-off-the-turf one-mile stakes last October at Belmont -- was such a disaster he was eased in the stretch. By the way, the horse who won that race, finishing 33 ¾ lengths ahead of Dean's Kitten, happened to be Eskendereya.

Runner-up Northern Giant ran a similar number on Polytrack as he had over Fair Grounds and Oaklawn dirt, but Beyers in the range of 89 to 91 don't inspire much Derby confidence.

SUNLAND DERBY

When Endorsement finished second in a Jan. 10 maiden race at Fair Grounds, then won a Feb. 20 maiden at Oaklawn, his respective pacelines were almost identical: 56-66-74-84F and 59-64-74-84F. Both races were leisurely-paced, and those aren't the numbers of your typical pace stalker.

Endorsement's workout pattern indicated he was on the improve (any time a horse works 59 4/5 at Fair Grounds, circle it with a bright yellow marker). But with Conveyance, Classical Slew and Tempted to Tapit in the Sunland Derby field, not even Endorsement's trainer, Shannon Ritter, expected the kind of trip he got. Conveyance had absolutely none of the expected early competition, cruising nonchalantly through a 60-71 pace for the first half-mile, with Endorsement right behind him through his own familiar pacefigs of 56-68. Given that Conveyance had a length-and-a-half lead with so little exerted energy, he would have been 1-to-20 at that point had bettors been allowed to play a race in progress. But Endorsement turned out to be a better horse than expected, shadowing Conveyance through a six-furlong pacefig of 83. When Conveyance kicked into high gear and delivered a solid mile pacefig of 93, Endorsement was not only alongside but edging away.

With that defeat, Conveyance dropped from my personal Top Ten. With that kind of pace setup, a legitimate Kentucky Derby contender should have run a career-best race instead of matching his 96 Beyer Speed Figure from the one-mile Southwest, the hottest-paced prep of the season thus far. That tells me a mile-and-eighth is outside his best distance, much less a mile-and-a-quarter.

A tepid endorsement of Endorsement: he is getting better quickly, and his 101 Beyer puts him right behind Eskendereya in the Derby speed-figure pecking order, but you couldn't go to the chalkboard and draw up a more perfect trip than what he got at Sunland. At that rate of early speed, Endorsement will find himself surrounded by a horde of horses at Churchill Downs.

Edgk More than 1 year ago
I don't follow how you compute this stuff. The Louisiana Derby was flat-out slow paced(horses ran the same distance 42 minutes later to compare). Sunland was a normal, competitive pace. The final time of the Louisiana Derby was good but uninspiring. The final time of the Sunland Derby was 1 or 2 tenths off the Track Record(not stakes record) for the distance. On top of that, Endorsement was the epitome of a horse that is said to have been "visually impressive", gobbling up ground in the lane with a smooth, athletic stride that stood out(and the final time confirmed it). It seems that you make your figures fit your opinions.
Chitownsteve75 More than 1 year ago
Good point Randy on your assessment of the Sunland Derby. Conveyance really had a chance to "move forward" off his last and faded badly in a 1 1/8th race. Baffert will enter him because he has the earnings and will be a rabbit for Lookin at Lucky, IMHO.
RAYBO More than 1 year ago
Love your professioanl commentary. One thought: Mission Impazible appeared to be totally blocked in the stretch run of the LA Derby and somehow he managed to break around other horses and accelerate to the lead. I think he has a solid chance at the Downs on May 1
Steve Goodwins More than 1 year ago
I think you are going to be surprised by Mission Impazible in the Ky.Derby. In addition to the fact this is the first time this horse has run this distance, he slammed HARD with another horse down the home stretch, and although the other horse really exhibited effects from the bump, Mission Impazible stayed strong and steady, and 100% maintained his composure. Also, it was VERY apparent, he was far from used up in the race, and will RELISH the added eighth of a mile in the Derby. Finishing is going to be this big horses strong suit. And, he will become more and more professional with each race. The way he pulled up, he appears to be a very sound individual as well.
race More than 1 year ago
Randy--Hi-- I agree with your take on the above prep races, and how they played out except I disagree with your comment that Desormeaux rode brilliantly in the L.A. Derby--holding inside on the rail, yes, that's fine around the first and second turn, but it looked like he lost his courage coming down the stretch, rather than Drusselmeyer not having enough stamina--race
ron More than 1 year ago
I agree that this year's Derby field has a lot of pace "quantity", but not much "quality" (speed). I can not remember a year where the top pace figs have been as slow. Can you? It seems in lean years, there has always been at least one burner, and those horses ran pretty well--Hard Spun, War Emblem ie, but this year Rule and Conveyance seem fastest. Hardly Songandaprayer types if you know what I mean. I think this type of set-up would make Endorsement an interesting play. Will you be publishing the pace lines for all this years Derby Preps, and when can we expect pace figs for turf races?
Curt A Vassallo More than 1 year ago
Randy, I read UR article nice & slow this time. I think U R right on. I know it's premature, considering the Wood is up next. But, I've seen no other horse in Eskendereya's class. He has tactical speed, & bred 4 the distance. He's undefeated on DIRT. Barring unforeseen circumstances, w/even a so so start, he should IMO, blow by these pretenders, w/alacrity down the stretch. Oh & BTW:having Seattle Slew, as his granddaddy, certainly improves his chances...